Shelby Hiter, Author at TechnologyAdvice https://technologyadvice.com/blog/author/shhiter/ We help B2B tech buyers manage the complex & risky buying process. Fri, 25 Oct 2024 18:43:00 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 https://assets.technologyadvice.com/uploads/2021/09/ta-favicon-45x45.png Shelby Hiter, Author at TechnologyAdvice https://technologyadvice.com/blog/author/shhiter/ 32 32 Asana vs monday: Top Project Management Software in 2024 https://technologyadvice.com/blog/project-management/asana-vs-monday/ Sat, 27 Apr 2024 02:47:36 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=68913 Discover Asana and Monday's key features, pros and cons, and pricing to help you decide which project management software better fits your needs.

The post Asana vs monday: Top Project Management Software in 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
Asana and monday.com are similar solutions for project management, but each one is optimized for different use cases. This analysis will cover each tool in greater detail, but first, here’s a quick summary of each tool’s greatest strengths:

  • Asana is better for task and workflow management as well as automation and integration opportunities.
  • monday.com is better for reporting, robust analytics, and a reliable network of customer support resources.
  • July 24, 2024: Shelby Hiter refreshed copy and data, reformatted and updated comparison tables, used a renewed and comprehensive scoring rubric to develop quantitative scores and a decisive methodology section, added in-depth analysis and explanations to each category, and added two new sections on collaboration/accessibility and customer support.
  • Apr. 26, 2024: Kaiti Norton updated our analysis with fresh information about each vendor’s current pricing and features.
  • Sept. 5. 2023: Corey Noles reviewed pricing and feature details for accuracy. He also made some adjustments to the copy to improve the flow of information.

At TechnologyAdvice, we assess a wide range of factors when evaluating project management software. Our process involves conducting hands-on demos, aggregating customer reviews, and reviewing product documentation in order to develop a comprehensive scoring rubric for each tool. As each vendor releases new software updates, we update our scoring rubric and this guide’s contents to provide you with the best insights.

Our scoring rubric focuses on the following core areas of project management functionality and performance. Each category is weighted according to its relative importance for the average project management user:

Task and workflow management – 20%

Within the task and workflow management review category, we not only focused on the presence of high-performance and user-friendly tasks and workflows but also the following key features:

  • Unlimited tasks/items
  • Multiple project views
  • Custom fields
  • Due dates
  • Subtasks (with hierarchy options)
  • Task dependencies
  • Recurring tasks
  • Project and task templates
  • Task multi-homing
  • Storage availability

Reporting and analytics – 20%

Our reporting and analytics assessment focused on quality, quantity, and diversity of reporting and analytics features, with special emphasis placed on availability and user-friendliness across different plan tiers. These were our primary subcategories:

  • Project dashboard availability and quality
  • Universal dashboards and reports
  • Report and dashboard customizability
  • Project portfolio management and reporting
  • Milestone/goal reporting and dashboarding

Automations and integrations – 20%

For automations and integrations, we looked at how easy it is to set up these kinds of workflows and what options were available across each plan tier. We also paid attention to the types and range of third-party integrations and prebuilt automations that were available. These were our focus areas:

  • Quantity of built-in third-party integrations
  • Proofing and approval workflows
  • Forms
  • AI-powered automation and support
  • Automation limitations
  • Integration limitations
  • Ease of use and setup for automation
  • Ease of use and setup for integration

Collaboration and accessibility – 15%

Because project management software is so often used by multiple users, many of whom have never used this type of software before, we decided that collaboration features and accessibility of the platform deserved its own review category. In this category, we looked specifically at tools and features that helped teammates to work better together and get needed visibility into their own and team responsibilities. We also focused on performance management, accountability management, and overall usability through the following subcategories:

  • In-app documents and document management
  • Activity log availability and quality
  • Admin console availability and quality
  • Assignees (including multiple assignees)
  • Mobile accessibility
  • Time tracking
  • Built-in messaging and commenting
  • Private projects
  • Guest access
  • Workload management and workload analytics
  • Communication integrations (Slack, email, etc.)
  • General ease of use

Support – 10%

Our customer support review process was pretty straightforward. We looked for multiple customer support channels, customer support resource availability, and how users have reviewed each platform in this category. Here are the subcategories we chose:

  • Customer support hours and availability
  • Phone support availability and quality
  • Live chat support availability and quality
  • Email/ticket support availability and quality
  • Knowledge base availability and quality
  • Premium support limitations
  • Community forum availability and quality
  • Live training availability and quality

Pricing – 10%

This was a particularly important category, as key features for each tool pop up in different plan tiers than you might expect. To assess pricing performance for each of these tools, we took a balanced approach that looked at affordability and value on a small scale and value and scalability for enterprise customers. Here’s what we emphasized in our research:

  • Overall value for money across all plans
  • Scalability of plans as you move from tier to tier
  • Free plan user seat limits
  • Free plan board/project limits
  • Free plan task/item limits
  • User seat limits on paid plans

User reviews – 5%

This category played the smallest role in our review, as we prefer to focus on the hands-on research we’ve conducted. However, it’s important to look at what customers are saying and how the two stack up when compared head-to-head on these popular review websites. We compared how each tool was rated overall on the following websites:

  • TrustRadius
  • Capterra
  • G2
  • Gartner Peer Insights

Asana vs. monday.com: Which is better?

Asana

monday.com

Pricing

✅

Customer Support

✅

Automations & Integrations

✅

Task & Workflow Management

✅

Reporting & Analytics

✅

Collaboration & Accessibility

✅

User Scores & Reviews

✅

Asana logo.

Asana: Better for task and workflow management

Overall Score

3.76/5

Pros

  • Unlimited projects, tasks, and storage on all plans.
  • More integration options.
  • Dynamic project structures and workflows.
  • Individual, team, and company-wide goal tracking.

Cons

  • Some customer support issues.
  • Larger learning curve.
  • Limited document management capabilities.
  • Basic project dashboards.

Who should choose Asana?

Asana works well for a wide range of use cases, but it has a slight edge if:

  • Your projects and workflows are complex.
  • You have no budget for project management software.
  • You have a team of 10 or fewer people.
  • You want streamlined goal tracking.

Asana’s flexible project management and task management tools will rise to the level of complexity you need. The platform allows you to monitor progress and stay ahead of potential risks by breaking down projects into multiple levels of tasks, subtasks, and even sub-subtasks. You also have complete control over project views, with options to group, sort, and filter tasks according to any field.

The software has other useful tools, like task dependencies, approvals, and batch actions. It also offers a great-value free plan, supporting up to 10 users at no additional cost. All in all, if you need to stay on top of many moving parts, Asana’s task management features are a strong choice for your team.

Project view customization: Control what details are displayed for your project and how. Organize by task type, status, owner, etc.

Task granularity: Asana allows you to break down assignments as thoroughly as necessary. Create tasks and subtasks with dependencies, then group tasks or establish dependencies to maintain the overall progress of your project.

High-level monitoring: Goal tracking and portfolio management features provide a birds’-eye view of progress and resources across multiple projects and teams.

The monday.com logo.

monday.com: Better for reporting

Overall Score

3.2/5

Pros

  • Comprehensive in-app document management.
  • 200+ project templates.
  • Strong multichannel customer support.
  • Wide variety of highly customizable dashboard widgets.

Cons

  • Frustrating limitations in free and low-tier paid plans.
  • Restrictive task hierarchies.
  • No prebuilt proofing and approval processes.
  • No top-level goal tracking.

Who should choose monday.com?

Choose monday.com if:

  • Your project structure is simple.
  • You need a fast implementation timeline.
  • You work well with hands-on customer support teams.
  • You want intricate tracking dashboards.

monday.com bills itself as a “work OS” or a platform that can manage workflows for everything, from HR to design to software development. The platform includes lots of project management tools, but you can also use it as a CRM, workflow automation tool, or collaboration tool.

monday.com is a standout solution for building custom dashboards and data analysis widgets, especially for users who want creative and highly visual widgets that can be filtered and adjusted to their specifications. And while monday.com is generally considered a user-friendly tool with no-code customizability, customers can also benefit from multichannel, 24/7 customer support.

Project template library: Choose from hundreds of templates for unique use cases — including several industry-specific scenarios — to get your project up and running quickly.

Dashboard customization: Dashboards offer tremendous versatility and numerous options to fine-tune data visualizations to your requirements. Several widgets, like Llama Farm, offer highly creative and fun ways to track different metrics for project progress.

App marketplace: Browse hundreds of apps (not to be confused with integrations) that have been curated by monday.com’s developer community to extend the software’s native functionality.

Asana vs. monday.com: Pricing

Winner: Asana

Here’s why: Asana and monday.com are structured similarly, with free-forever plans that graduate incrementally to custom enterprise packages. However, while monday.com offers slightly lower starting prices for its paid plans, Asana offers more value and comprehensive features in its free plan by a landslide (more rationale and analysis available in Analysis tab).

Comparison

Asana

monday work management

Free plan available?

✔

✔

Starting price for paid plans*

$10.99

$9

Free trial length

30 days

14 days

Discount for annual billing

✔

✔

Maximum free plan seats

10

2

Maximum free plan project count

Unlimited projects and boards

Up to 3 project boards

Maximum free plan task/item count

Unlimited tasks

Up to 1,000 items (tasks)

Seat limits on paid plans

Up to 500 users on Starter and Advanced plans

Unlimited users in all paid plans

Functional free plan

✔

*per user per month, with annual billing

Asana

Score: 4.25 out of 5 stars.

Asana has five main pricing tiers:

  • Personal: $0 for up to 10 user seats.
  • Starter: $10.99 per user per month, billed annually, or $13.49 per user per month, billed monthly.
  • Advanced: $24.99 per user per month, billed annually, or $30.49 per user per month, billed monthly.
  • Enterprise: Custom quote.
  • Enterprise+: Custom quote.

The free plan allows up to 10 users, which means it could work for a small team that needs several project and task management features but has little or no budget available. Even in the free tier, Asana includes access to unlimited projects, tasks, file storage, activity logs, and messages.

Most teams, though, will want at least the Starter plan to meet their needs. Moving up to this pricing tier gives you access to workflow automation, unlimited free guests, Gantt chart views, and other tools that will level up your project management capabilities.

monday.com

Score: 3.25 out of 5 stars.

monday work management has five tiers:

  • Free: $0 for up to 2 seats and several limitations.
  • Basic: $9 per seat per month, billed annually, or $12 per seat per month, billed monthly.
  • Standard: $12 per seat per month, billed annually, or $14 per seat per month, billed monthly.
  • Pro: $19 per seat per month, billed annually, or $24 per seat per month, billed monthly.
  • Enterprise: Custom quote.

monday.com also offers comparable plans for its specialized products, monday sales CRM and monday dev.

While monday.com does offer a free plan, its inclusions are too limited for most teams. For example, free plan accounts can only have two users, three boards, and no integrations or automations. Even the Basic plan, which is the first paid tier, lacks essentials like automations, calendar and timeline views, and guest access.

Most businesses should expect to pay between $12 and $19 per user per month for the mid-tier Standard or Pro plans. These plans both get you software integrations, workflow automation, and more project views, but the Pro plan gives you more of all of those. If your team needs extensive admin and enterprise security capabilities, you’ll want to talk with monday’s team directly about Enterprise plan pricing.

Analysis

Asana

You get pretty much everything an individual user or even a small team would need in the free plan, especially since this plan includes access to unlimited tasks, projects, messages, file storage, and activity logs (although not much in the way of reporting and dashboarding). The free plan also has a wide variety of project views, which is really helpful. Most importantly for project teams, this free plan is generous enough to offer access for up to 10 users. 

The way features scale up with each Asana tier makes sense, and I love that Asana breaks its plans down between those that are ideal for individuals and small teams and those that are ideal for businesses and enterprises. The Enterprise and Enterprise+ plans offer impressive features for administration, security, data management, and more. 

Asana’s paid-tier plans each have great features at mostly solid prices, though it’s significant that there isn’t really a pricing equivalent in Asana to monday’s Standard plan. Instead, pricing more than doubles when moving from Starter to Advanced, which isn’t ideal if you need to upgrade but don’t want to take such a huge leap with your budget.

Pricing for paid plans is also a bit misleading, so be aware. Both the Starter and Advanced plans require you to have at least two users on your account. So although the price technically starts at $10.99 and $24.99 for each of these plans, the real minimum cost is more like $21.98 and $49.98, respectively.

monday.com

monday’s packaging approach isn’t terrible but it also isn’t great, especially in the lower tiers. As an individual managing just my own projects, I was frustrated by how quickly I ran out of space in my workspace. Even just while managing work and tasks for one person, I ran out of space within a year; working within the confines of only 1,000 items and three boards is incredibly limiting. 

I also was frustrated by the fact that both the free plan and the lowest-tier paid plan didn’t have any views beyond the kanban view. I really wanted the calendar view to better visualize my deadlines, but since this feature is only available in the second of the paid tiers, I had to upgrade to the Standard plan to get what I needed. Unfortunately, that plan (and all paid monday.com plans) require you to pay for at least three seats, even if you only need one seat. Several other features are weak or missing at the lower tiers, so you pretty much have to upgrade to more expensive plans to get full functionality. 

However, reporting and dashboarding are pretty solid at the lowest tiers, as is customer support availability and team collaboration capabilities. Also, an important thing to highlight: despite the limitation of only two users per free plan account, all paid plans support unlimited users.

Asana vs. monday.com: Task and workflow management

Winner: Asana

Here’s why: monday.com’s project template library will help you jumpstart your project if you’re pressed for time, but its task management capabilities are relatively inflexible. Asana, on the other hand, gives you granular control over how your projects are structured and organized so your team can work more efficiently. It’s clear that Asana was specifically designed for task and task hierarchy management (more rationale and analysis available in Analysis tab).

Comparison

Asana

monday work management

Project templates

80+

200+

Unlimited tasks/items

✔

In paid plans

Multiple subtask levels (hierarchies)

✔

Kanban, Gantt, and table views

✔

Limited views across plans

Task dependencies

✔

In certain paid plans

Recurring tasks

✔

Task multi-homing

✔

Unlimited storage

✔

Asana

Score: 4.63 out of 5 stars.

Asana offers several compelling advantages over monday.com when it comes to managing complex workflows and tasks. First, Asana’s interface makes it easier to customize any project view to your requirements. You can group tasks by type, status, owner, due date, etc. and sort within those groups to see what’s most important in different circumstances.

It also lets you break down projects into units that make sense for your team, whether that’s tasks, subtasks, or sub-subtasks. Task hierarchy is extensive here, allowing users to set up as many as five degrees of dependent subtasks. 

However, you can’t assign one task to multiple people, which means you have to distill tasks into their simplest components. While some users are frustrated by this limitation, others appreciate that it forces a level of granularity that encourages accountability and clear communication. In comparison, monday.com’s capabilities are limited to one level of subtasks that struggle to show up accurately with reporting and automations.

Asana project view.
Asana offers multiple user-friendly project views, including a kanban board. Source: Asana

monday.com

Score: 2.81 out of 5 stars.

monday work management isn’t as dynamic as Asana when it comes to task and workflow management. This is especially apparent when looking at monday’s task-setup capabilities. Only one level of subtask hierarchy is possible, and task dependencies, recurring tasks, and task multi-homing are all either only available in higher-tier plans or require users to do their own complicated customizations. 

However, despite these shortcomings, monday.com does offer an impressive range of pre-configured categories, which support easier tracking and collaboration down the line. For example, you can choose from more than 30 types of columns when building or customizing a board:

  • Status
  • Label
  • Priority
  • People
  • Number
  • Text
  • Long text
  • Timeline
  • Date
  • Creative brief
  • Meeting notes
  • Checkbox
  • World clock
  • Link
  • Item ID
  • Phone number
  • Location
  • Files
  • Vote
  • Rating
  • Tags
  • Creation log
  • Last updated
  • Progress tracking
  • Button
  • Dependency
  • Dropdown
  • Week
  • Formula
  • Country
  • Color picker
  • Time tracking
  • Email address

Some of these column types are slight variations of the same thing (Text and Long text, for example) that can be accomplished with customizations in Asana. However, some columns like World clock, Formula, Button, and Rating offer a unique functionality that would take considerably more effort to replicate in Asana. Columns in the monday app can’t be customized to the same degree as those in Asana, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing if you don’t have the time or patience to fuss with building something from scratch.

To that end, monday.com’s vast library of templates range from broad use cases like marketing strategy to niche ones like real estate agency management. These templates demonstrate numerous ways monday.com can adapt to different industries, teams, projects, and workflows with little manual effort.

Analysis

Asana

Asana really shines in this category. Based on my experience with Asana, monday.com, and other similar PM platforms, I think Asana is the best overall for task and workflow management. 

It is an incredible tool not just for visualizing and setting up tasks, but also for setting up task hierarchies that make sense and break down the project so everyone can understand and take responsibility for their tasks and subtasks. Also, unlike monday and several other tools, recurring tasks and task dependencies are built in as features at all levels, including in the free plan, which is great for teams that really want to drill down into the specifics. The tool also offers a generous range of project view options, including in its free plan.

I was surprised and impressed by the granularity you can achieve with Asana task hierarchy. Users can develop a task hierarchy with up to five levels per task. Admittedly, this would probably be overkill for most projects. But for projects with dozens of teammates, complex requirements and dependencies, or a long timeline where details get filled in over time, this kind of hierarchy is likely to come in handy.

Asana’s project and task templates are available in all paid plans. Its templates are really well done and useful, though the available options and industry-specific templates are somewhat lacking. However, I would choose Asana over monday if I’m most interested in setting up custom task templates.

monday.com

monday.com can handle most of the basics pretty well and is especially good at offering useful project templates to its customers. However, it has some pretty important shortcomings for task and workflow management, especially when compared to Asana. Subtask hierarchy is nonexistent (although you can have multiple subtasks), multiple project views are only available in the top three tiers, and recurring tasks and task multi-homing can only be set up through complex workarounds that may or may not actually work even after all that effort. Storage is also limited.

monday’s limitations for project views are probably the most disappointing here. The kanban view is the only view available in its Free and Basic plans. Timeline, Calendar, and Map views become available in the Standard plan. And Chart view is only available in the Pro and Enterprise plans. The limitations here are a big reason why I ended up upgrading from the free plan, despite only being one user.

For users who want task and workflow management that makes sense and requires little configuration, though, monday is actually a great solution because of its well-designed project templates. The tool’s 200+ project templates — a really solid collection with a wide variety of coverage — are available in all plans. In my opinion, monday.com does a better job than Asana of categorizing and providing templates for industry-specific requirements.

Asana vs. monday.com: Reporting & analytics

Winner: monday.com

Here’s why: Asana’s analytics capabilities are sufficient for basic project reports, but monday.com offers more variety and customization in terms of data visualization. monday.com’s first-party data architecture, mondayDB, is also better for maintaining large, complex dashboards (more rationale and analysis available in Analysis tab).

Comparison

Asana

monday work management

Dashboard widget format options

7

40+

Per-dashboard widget limit

20

30

Dashboards in free plan?

✔

Exportable reports

Granular visualization controls

✔

First-party data infrastructure

✔

Goal and milestone tracking

✔

Asana

Score: 3.06 out of 5 stars.

Asana’s analytics capabilities are pretty basic. Each project dashboard has seven chart formats for data visualization:

  • Bar charts.
  • Stacked bar charts.
  • Line graphs.
  • Donut charts.
  • Burnup charts.
  • Lollipop charts.
  • Numbers custom field sum charts.

You can tweak each chart’s axes and color palette, but it’s missing some of the controls monday.com offers for sizing, ascending/descending axes, and multi-dimensional charts. Similarly, Asana’s widget filters are less dynamic and can be a little tricky to configure correctly.

Asana has several reporting and analytics limitations, with the most important one being that free plan users do not have access to dashboarding or reporting features. In paid plans, Asana is also more limited in terms of widget quantity — each dashboard maxes out at 20 widgets, so if you need more depth or detail, you’ll need to export the data to a different platform. Thankfully, Asana’s Google Sheets integration makes this relatively easy.

Outside of project-specific dashboards and plan-specific limitations, though, Asana has some compelling analytics features, especially when it comes to team and performance management. The Goals dashboard, for example, is reminiscent of performance management software. You can set up cascading goals at the company, team, or individual level and drill into more granular sub-goals and related work. This setup makes it easy to see how individual projects and tasks contribute to broader goals without much manual configuration.

monday.com

Score: 3.38 out of 5 stars.

monday.com’s greatest strength lies in its analytics capabilities. In mid-2023, the company announced the launch of mondayDB, its database architecture that powers the software’s boards and dashboards. mondayDB is a more flexible and secure infrastructure solution compared to most alternatives — it’s still in its first version, so particularly complex queries on large datasets tend to lag a bit, but monday.com’s product roadmap promises better performance at a larger scale in the coming months.

Beyond the database infrastructure, monday.com’s dashboard widgets offer extensive data visualization options that are incredibly user-friendly and intuitive. You can choose from a large library of 40+ widgets to build a dashboard with the precise details you need to track what’s most important. It has all of the standard charts and graphs you’d expect, plus unique widgets for things like workload management, geo-mapping, and date countdowns. The app marketplace offers additional visualization options for niche use cases as well.

Like Asana, monday.com lacks the ability to generate ready-made, exportable reports, but you can export individual widgets as PDFs, PNGs, SVGs, and other file formats.

Learn more about monday.com’s dashboards in our 2-part video overview:

Analysis

Asana

Asana is really lacking when it comes to general reporting and dashboarding features, but it is a stellar performer when it comes to goals and milestones. It’s also pretty solid for usability, and it’s nice that certain plans support custom report fields (an advantage over monday). However, this tool’s reporting feels less user-friendly and is incredibly limited in the free plan. Especially for free plan teams that have as many as 10 users, I think this limitation would cause major longterm performance and progress tracking issues.

Its greatest strengths in this area are related to PPM reporting and milestone and goal reporting. For project portfolio management, portfolio workload reporting and dashboarding becomes available in the Advanced and Enterprise plans. In contrast, it’s unclear if monday’s work performance insights feature can be configured to do portfolio-wide reporting (though custom filters could certainly help).

Milestones are available in all paid plans, and Goals (as well as a full Goals project view) are available in the Advanced and Enterprise plans. While using this tool, I found that the Milestones and Goals parts of the platform were both easy to access and allow users to add a lot of detail. This is a clear strength area for Asana’s reporting and dashboarding that could otherwise use some improvements.

monday.com

While monday.com has some definite reporting and dashboarding shortcomings — especially for dashboard field customizability and goal/milestone reporting — it’s hard to beat the visual quality and usability of this tool’s reporting feature. What’s more, dashboards are available in all plans, including the free plan. Being able to use the basic widgets while I was still a free user of the tool gave me the confidence I needed to invest in a paid plan with even more high-quality dashboard widgets.

Unlimited dashboards are available in all plans. One board per dashboard is what’s possible for Free and Basic plan users. Standard allows up to five boards’ data to be combined and reviewed in a dashboard. Pro allows up to 10 boards. And Enterprise allows up to 50 boards. So although monday.com doesn’t directly advertise portfolio-wide reporting, the number of boards you can put on a Pro or Enterprise dashboard would fulfill most portfolio-wide reporting needs. 

I am personally a fan of the wide variety and visual quality of dashboard widgets on monday.com — it is one of its biggest selling points for me, because it makes reporting interesting and easier to manage, even for less-technical users.

Asana vs. monday.com: Automations & integrations

Winner: Asana

Here’s why: Both Asana and monday.com have user-friendly, no-code solutions for automations and integrations, but Asana wins for its sheer availability. Unlimited integrations are possible to set up in all plans, and automations can be set up in all paid plans. In contrast, monday.com only allows automation and integration setup in its top three plans (more rationale and analysis available in Analysis tab).

Comparison

Asana

monday work management

Available integrations

400+

Between 100 and 200*

Integrations on all plans

✔

Unlimited integration actions

✔

Open API access

✔

✔

AI automations and support

All paid plans

Some paid plans

Automations on all plans

All paid plans

Some paid plans

Unlimited automation actions

Enterprise-tier plans only

Forms

All paid plans

✔

Proofing and approvals

Some paid plans

*monday.com offers additional apps that are separate from integrations.

Asana

Score: 3.94 out of 5 stars.

With Asana, you get access to more than 400 popular app integrations like Microsoft Teams, Google Workspace, Figma, Jira, Slack, and Zoom. Most integrations are available n all Asana plans, but a handful of apps like Salesforce, Tableau, Power BI, and Adobe Creative Cloud are restricted to the higher paid plans. For the majority of use cases, though, the app you need to integrate is available for free.

Asana also offers open API access and works well with automation platforms like Zapier and Make. This is a nice workaround to automate basic processes for free, and it’s a must-have for complex flows that exceed Asana’s native capabilities.

On the automation front, Asana supports automations across all of its paid plans, allowing for 250 actions per month in the Starter plan, 25,000 actions per month in the Advanced plan, and unlimited automations per month in both the Enterprise and Enterprise+ plans. Additional strengths of Asana include proofing and approval workflows available to Advanced and Enterprise customers, forms in all paid plans, and a robust suite of AI automation and assistance tools via Asana AI.

Asana friction elimination.
Asana eliminates friction from your workflows that work with apps like Google Drive. Source: Asana

monday.com

Score: 2.69 out of 5 stars.

monday.com’s approach to integrations is confusing at best and downright frustrating at worst. The integration library includes about 100 essential business apps that sync directly with your board, but you can’t actually use them unless you’re subscribed to the Standard plan or higher, where integrations first become available as a feature.

What’s more, monday.com limits both integration and automation usage — the Standard plan gets you 250 integration and automation actions per month, while the Pro plan bumps you up to 25,000, and even the Enterprise plan does not support unlimited integrations or automations. This structure can drive up costs quickly, especially if you have a large team that often works cross-functionally. Even connecting to a platform like Zapier requires a webhook integration, so there aren’t any viable workarounds like there are with Asana.

One advantage monday.com offers, though, is its app marketplace. While the integrations are primarily used to sync data with other platforms, apps serve to extend monday.com’s native functionality. Things like embedding Google Docs in an item card, for example, can be accomplished without setting up an integration. Another handful of monday.com advantages include forms and shareable forms in all plans (including the free plan) and a user interface for integrations and automations that is more intuitive than most — including Asana.

Learn more about monday.com’s integrations in our video overview:

Analysis

Asana

I can’t identify any real feature gaps here, just some limitations in lower-tier plans. Asana offers a great integration volume and range, solid proofing and approval opportunities, and a generous quantity of integration and automation actions at each pricing tier. Asana Intelligence seems to be one of the better AI assistants in PM right now. Limitations in lower-tier plans are about on par with most competitors.

Asana AI is available in all paid plans for AI automation and assistance, which is a huge plus. Features include smart statuses, smart goals, smart summaries, smart rules, the smart editor, smart fields, and smart projects. “Teammates” is a newer feature that gives insights about teams and tools and areas of strategic focus through the perspective of a virtual teammate, which also handles task automation and workflow orchestration. Coming soon in Asana AI are smart charts, smart onboarding, and AI teammate chat capabilities. From what I’m seeing, this is one of the best AI in PM solutions on the market today.

As far as ease of use goes, I would say that Asana is a great option for both technical and nontechnical users. It is particularly well suited to more complex integration and automation scenarios. Though, because of this strength, many users report that this tool could benefit from being more visual and that it has a steeper learning curve than some others, including monday.com.

monday.com

monday.com’s automation and integration features are great where they are available. No proofing and approval processes are built in, and no integration or automation opportunities are available in the bottom two plans. It’s kind of crazy to me that even the lowest-tier PAID plan doesn’t support these kinds of actions. Basically, you’re in a bad spot if you want integrations or automations as an individual user. However, despite these clear shortfalls, automations and integrations are relatively easy to set up and have a very visual interface with if/then logic, which is friendly to all user types.

monday AI is only available as part of the Pro and Enterprise plans at this time. Back when it was a beta feature, it was accessible in all paid plans, and I was able to use it in my Standard plan account, but this is no longer an option. Current AI features include AI templates and workflows, AI categorization, sentiment analysis, AI summarization, action item suggestions, content translation. I am especially impressed with the sentiment analysis feature and the general capabilities of this AI when it comes to processing large amounts of product data, including qualitative data.

Other than its user-friendly design, monday.com’s greatest strength in this category is its approach to forms. While forms are available in all paid plans in Asana, monday.com users can access forms in both free and paid plan accounts. Shareable forms are available across all plans, and unlimited forms are available to Pro and Enterprise users.

Asana vs. monday.com: Collaboration & accessibility

Winner: Asana, but just barely

Here’s why: Asana narrowly surpassed monday.com’s score with its impressive baseline features as well as its activity logs, admin console, and guest access features that support enterprise scalability. But what’s interesting here is monday excels in areas where Asana doesn’t and vice-versa. monday is great for multiple assignees and document management. The mobile app is also super easy to navigate, but its enterprise scalability across plans is less impressive (more rationale and analysis available in Analysis tab).

Comparison

Asana

monday work management

User limits on free plan

Up to 10 users

Up to 2 users

Activity logs

Unlimited in all plans

Limited across all plans

Admin console

All paid plans

Some paid plans

Messaging and commenting

✔

✔

Guest access

All paid plans

Some paid plans

In-app document management

Limited

✔

Private projects

All paid plans

Some paid plans

Workload management and analytics

Some paid plans

Some paid plans

Communication integrations

✔

Some paid plans

Multiple assignees

✔

@mentions

✔

✔

Asana

Score: 3.13 out of 5 stars.

Asana’s built-in collaboration features are excellent across all plans, which is evident even in its free plan that allows up to 10 users to collaborate seamlessly. Users are treated to unlimited messages and commenting, unlimited assignees (though there’s no way to set up multiple assignees on a single task), relevant communication integrations, a capable mobile app version, and unlimited activity logs. The unlimited activity logs feature is a huge plus that allows teams to track their progress and hold different teammates accountable across different stages of a project. In contrast, none of monday’s plans offer an unlimited activity log option.

As far as weaknesses go, Asana falls short in an area where monday.com really shines: documents and document management. Sure, Asana users can attach files from external sources directly to tasks and workflows, but from there, there does not seem to be a central repository or workspace where users can access these documents; the only way to find them is if you click on them directly from the task(s) where they are attached. This is a definite shortcoming, but Asana works to mitigate it with its integrations with several cloud storage systems.

Speaking on general ease of use, Asana is a fairly easy-to-use tool but can be overwhelming to users with less PM platform experience. Incredible amounts of detail can be added to each task and subtask, and everything is very clearly labeled. It’s also really easy to add milestones and goals, so everyone knows what they’re working toward. Although this platform feels less visual and color-coded than monday.com, it makes up for it with all of the easy-to-access features and additions for task management.

monday.com

Score: 3.06 out of 5 stars.

monday.com is an excellent tool for collaboration and accessibility, giving users a colorful and customizable tool where they can clearly identify what teammates are working on. Multiple assignees for a single item or subitem are easy to set up regardless of your plan. This is a major advantage for tasks or groups of tasks that are owned by an entire team or several different team players; after all, it’s not always possible or prudent to break down ownership beyond that point, as Asana requires all users to do.

monday’s greatest strengths in this category lie in its approach to document management and the approachability of its overall interface. Embedded documents are available in all plans, and private docs are available in the Pro and Enterprise plans. Unlimited docs are available in all paid plans, and generally speaking, the platform offers really great doc usability through its intuitive interface. It’s not quite at the level of an office suite tool, but it has way more capabilities than you’d expect for a built-in document storage and management tool.

Compared to Asana, monday.com’s lower-tier plans have some collaborative weaknesses, with the most obvious being that only two users can be added to the free plan. Its approach to activity logs is perhaps the most frustrating for larger, data-driven teams. The most you can get for monday.com activity logs is five years in the Enterprise plan, while both the Free and Basic plans only provide activity logs for up to a week.

Analysis

Asana

While not all collaboration-focused features are available in the free plan, many are, and nearly all others are an option across all paid plans. Among these features is the admin console, which is highly capable and includes several different, adjustable controls. I will say, though, the interface for this feature is a tad overwhelming because of all the elements that come with it.

The guest access and guest access management features in Asana also stand out and are available in all paid plans. Unlimited free guests can be added to any paid plan, while guest invite controls are available in both Enterprise plans and trusted guest domains can be configured in Enterprise+ accounts.

iOS and Android mobile apps are available for all plans, and mobile data controls are available in both Enterprise and Enterprise+ plans. Generally, user reviews say that Asana’s mobile interface is clean and easy to read/use. I tend to agree based on my experience. 

I have to say, I was really surprised and disappointed by Asana’s approach to in-app document management — or its lack thereof. You can attach files from external sources to your tasks, including images and PDFs, but you’re really limited beyond that. For example, when I linked a Google doc to one of my Asana tasks, I found that it just goes directly to that doc and leaves the platform entirely, which disrupts the whole user experience.

Additionally, it seems like file uploads have to be directly attached to a specific project task — they can’t be universally uploaded. There also isn’t a folder system or way to categorize and organize these file attachments, and there’s no version control or advanced search either. However, there are integrations for cloud storage systems. Also, you can attach these files to approval and proofing workflows directly, which is convenient.

In sum, as long as you’re not trying to use Asana to replace or supplement your current content creation and collaborative workspace tools, you should have all of the collaboration features you need in this tool.

monday.com

I was generally surprised to see that monday performs best in areas where Asana doesn’t and vice-versa. This was especially shocking, considering how closely these two compete and try to outperform each other. Overall, monday is great for multiple assignees and document management. The mobile app is also super easy to navigate. However, its activity logs, guest access, and communication integration capabilities are quite lacking, especially in its lower tiers.

Sure, an activity log is available across all plans, but every monday.com plan has its limits. One week is available for Free and Basic, six months for Standard, one year for Pro, and five years for Enterprise. This could be crippling, depending on teams’ workflows and project timelines. Even in my solopreneur work, I quickly became discouraged by the lack of data I could access from my previous year’s client work. This is not a problem in any Asana plan.

I also don’t love monday’s approach to guest access. Limited guest access starts to be offered in the Standard plan, with four guests billed as one seat. Unlimited guest access doesn’t become available until the Pro and Enterprise tiers. To slightly make up for this weakness, monday does allow unlimited free viewers in all paid plans; these individuals are given read-only access.

monday.com really delivers when it comes to general ease of use, even when compared to the user-friendly Asana. The platform operates with an easy kanban-style interface; the other project views are pretty straightforward too, if you’re willing to pay for the higher-tier plans where they’re available. Color-coding, custom fields and columns, assignees and due dates, etc. all make it really easy to see what you’re doing, what your teammates are doing, and how projects are progressing. Its document and whiteboard features are also quite useful, especially since they help users to differentiate between formal project documentation and brainstorming space.

Asana vs. monday.com: Support

Winner: monday.com

Here’s why: Both monday.com and Asana have earned high marks for customer service and support in user reviews, but while Asana lacks some multichannel and 24/7 availability in certain plans, monday.com offers comprehensive support resources — both guided and self-service — across all of its plans (more rationale and analysis available in Analysis tab).

Comparison

Asana

monday work management

24/7 support

Enterprise plans only

All paid plans

Phone

Limited

Live chat

Limited

✔

Email/ticket

✔

✔

Self-service knowledge base

✔

✔

Community forum

✔

✔

Live training

✔

✔

Asana

Score: 3.25 out of 5 stars.

Asana’s support features are mostly high-quality solutions. The lack of phone support and limitations on 24/7 support were the biggest weaknesses here. I wasn’t a fan of the chatbot either. In general, though, I was pleased with its collection of self-service and self-help resources — especially its comprehensive documentation — and its live training setup.

Phone support does not appear to be an option for users on any plan, and 24/7 support is only available for Enterprise and Enterprise+ users, which is a major ding for its support reputation against monday, which offers 24/7 support on all paid plans. And while Asana does have a live chat feature, it quickly became clear to me that it is entirely bot-powered and not capable of answering even some of my simpler account questions.

But Asana really puts in the work for its Asana Help Center ticketing system and its Asana Guide knowledge base. It also has one of the more impressive collections of live trainings that I’ve seen. Several different live training options available for free, even without an account. Training is also available in different languages, including English, French, German, Japanese, and Spanish.

monday.com

Score: 4.13 out of 5 stars.

monday.com is already an easy-to-use tool, but when you add in its top-tier support capabilities, I find it to be one of the most user-friendly options available today. There are very few limitations here. I love the multichannel support options, though there are some limitations on the customer’s agency, specifically for how phone calls work. 

monday.com’s 24/7 support is available to all paid plan users, which is a major advantage compared to many of its direct competitors, including Asana. Its live chat, ticketing, and knowledge base setups are also straightforward and effortless, giving fairly accurate answers to nearly all of the questions I could think of. I was surprised and happy to see that its email and ticket support resources were available to me even when I logged out of my account, though that may cause them to occasionally overcommit to lower-priority issues and questions.

The only disadvantage I can find with monday’s support approach is that certain premium support features, including a dedicated CSM, are only available in the highest-tier plans. Other than that, customers should expect a strong customer service experience, even during onboarding and implementation.

Analysis

Asana

I said most of what I needed to say about Asana support in the section above, but there is one weakness I want to highlight: its live chat feature was almost unusable for certain queries I posed, which is a serious problem. While configuring this analysis, I asked two questions in the Asana chat that should have been very simple to answer. 

Not only did the bot not answer me, it just provided linked articles and resources — and the resources provided were on a completely unrelated topic. I looked for ways to surpass the bot and get to a human representative for better support, but I could not find a way to do that. So if chat support is a huge deciding factor for you, I would probably look elsewhere.

At the same time, even as a new user, I was able to find the answers to most of my questions in Asana’s documentation. They have some of the most detailed documentation I’ve seen and do a great job of anticipating both general and niche questions buyers may have.

monday.com

The platform’s 24/7 support is available in all paid plans, and all of monday’s user-friendly self-service features are available to free plan users. Additionally, phone support seems to be a unique advantage that monday offers, though it’s set up in an odd way. From what I can tell, as long as you have a monday.com account, you can request a phone call from the monday team. However, you can’t directly call them, as no phone numbers are listed.

Live chat does seem to be available in all plans, including the free plan, and it’s given me pretty straightforward and accurate responses so far. As a note, I did ask one question where the bot said it wasn’t able to help and then asked if I would like to be handed off to a support agent for more details. When I said yes, the chat ran into “some sort of technical issue,” so the question was not resolved. I’m not sure if this is a typical experience or a one-time error that I experienced.

As far as live training goes, I think monday is actually better than it advertises. The monday.com pricing page says I can’t access live webinars without a paid account. To test if this was true, I logged out of my account and used a non-account email; from there, I was able to sign up for the live training they have today, so I don’t think this is an actual limitation. The main limitation is that they only show one live webinar sign-up option at a time, usually for that particular day, so it would be difficult to plan ahead.

Asana vs. monday.com: Ready to choose?

Both Asana and monday.com are popular project management tools that can help your team plan workflows, automate tasks, and track projects and tasks. However, they aren’t built exactly the same:

  • Asana offers more robust task management tools overall. It also offers a better free plan that small teams can actually use, and it gives you more access to software integrations.
  • monday.com, on the other hand, is a more straightforward project management platform with an analytical backbone. It’s a great solution if you don’t have the time, patience, or technical expertise to create a bespoke project ecosystem, especially with its top-tier customer support approach.

If neither Asana nor monday sounds quite right for your team, check out popular alternatives in our Project Management Software Guide.

FAQs

The core features of Asana and monday.com include project management, task management, and workflow automation.

In most situations, Asana offers more customization and granular task management capabilities, while monday.com’s platform offers more project templates and better reporting capabilities.

The post Asana vs monday: Top Project Management Software in 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
Asana vs monday: Top Project Management Software in 2024 Asana and monday are two of the top PM solutions. Compare pricing & features so you can pick the right solution. asana,faq,monday.com,Project Management,asana vs monday asana-logo asana-task-calendar asana-project asana Tableau Dashboard asana-workflows Workflows in Asana asana gantt Monday.com Logo monday.com Customizable Boards Create highly customizable boards with monday.com’s work OS. Source: monday.com Groups in Monday.com monday.com Workspaces monday.com makes it easy to create your workspace. Source: monday.com monday.com Integrations Integrate monday.com with many apps, including Jira software. Source: monday.com Maps in Monday.com asana project view Asana offers multiple user-friendly project views, including a kanban board. Source: Asana asana friction elimination Asana eliminates friction from your workflows that work with apps like Google Drive. Source: Asana
What Are Project Milestones & How to Use Them https://technologyadvice.com/blog/information-technology/project-milestones/ Tue, 23 Jul 2024 18:52:53 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=127486 Milestones are fundamental in project management. Learn what they are, how to create them, and how to use them for a successful project.

The post What Are Project Milestones & How to Use Them appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
  • Project milestones are strategic progress checkpoints within a larger project.
  • Project milestones should be set collaboratively by project managers and key stakeholders or clients.
  • Many project management software solutions offer built-in milestone trackers and templates that can help your team stay on track.
TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured partners

What is a project milestone?

A project milestone is a strategic point in a project’s timeline when a certain subtask, event, phase, or goal is completed. Whether you’re operating a short-term or long-term project, incorporating milestones is an effective way to manage how time and resources are spent. 

Here’s a quick breakdown of how project milestones differ from other key project management terms:

  • Milestone vs. task: A milestone is a trackable sub-goal that’s composed of more granular tasks and sub-tasks.
  • Milestone vs. deliverable: While a deliverable is a specific goal or outcome that the project team hopes to achieve, a milestone is typically the achievement of one or multiple of these deliverables.
  • Milestone vs. KPI: Key performance indicators (KPIs) measure performance across multiple metrics throughout a project, whereas milestones represent achievements at specific points in the project. KPIs are often used to analyze progress toward milestones. 

Project milestones are typically set jointly by the project team’s leader and key decision-maker(s). They should be specific, measurable, and strategically timed throughout a project’s lifecycle.

Benefits of milestones in project management

While setting project milestones can feel like an arduous task, many benefits come from breaking down your projects with milestones in mind:

  • Clearer project phases and improved task prioritization: Especially for long-term projects, it can be difficult to decide what’s important now and what will be important later. Setting milestones helps all team members prioritize the current tasks on their plates so they can more effectively move on when it’s time rather than multitasking.
  • Built-in pauses and pivot points: Milestones give teams a chance to reflect on what is and isn’t working so far. With this pause, both the project team and the client can evaluate if changes are needed while also identifying new risks that need to be mitigated in the next project phase.
  • Clearly defined roles and responsibilities: Milestones and the tasks underneath them often have owners who are responsible for their success. With this organizational structure, it will be clear who is working on what and give teammates the chance to more effectively communicate and collaborate because they are familiar with each other’s workloads.
  • Regular progress reports for stakeholders: Progress toward milestones can be tracked in multiple ways, including through visual reports and dashboards. These quantitative illustrations can be shown to clients and other stakeholders who want to see results regularly.
  • Improved budget, resource, and timeline management: Milestones help project managers plan every detail, focus on what’s most important, and assign their resources accordingly. Depending on what milestone is next on the list, the project manager can determine how much of their budget and other resources should be used or saved for a later milestone that needs those resources more.
  • Boosted project team morale: Each time an important project milestone is achieved will feel like a big win for your team. Setting up milestones is an effective way to give project teams something to look forward to and celebrate at regular intervals, rather than waiting to celebrate until the very end of a project.

How to use project milestones effectively

Project milestones are most helpful when they are set strategically and reviewed periodically. To determine project milestones that help your team more clearly visualize and reach their goals, follow these best practices and tips:

Set clear milestones from the start

Similar to SMART goals, your project milestones should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and timely. The most important part of this equation is timeliness: When should this milestone be completed in relation to other milestones and the project at large? Additionally, what tasks, resources, and team members need to align with this milestone for it to be a success? Answering these questions from the beginning of your process will help you create milestones that successfully showcase progress toward project deliverables and goals.

Distribute strategic milestones throughout the project lifecycle

Milestones should not only fall at the beginning and end of the project but also at multiple points during the project. Any time a specific task or goal needs to be completed by a certain date or for future tasks to get underway, look for ways to frame that work as a measurable milestone. This will segment your project into more focused and thoughtful sections and give both your clients and project team members more motivators to get to the next project phase quickly.

Collaboratively set and communicate milestones with key stakeholders

Project teams and clients bring unique perspectives and expertise to each project, so it’s important for both sides to co-create project milestones. This ensures transparency and alignment and also allows both teams to push back where resourcing, budgets, or internal skills may become an issue.

Once milestones have been set, the project manager or the owners responsible for individual milestones should clearly and frequently communicate about progress toward and challenges surrounding milestones. This will help both organizations prepare for best- and worst-case scenarios where milestones may need to be altered.

Use project management tools

Many project management platforms include milestone management features, templates, reports, dashboards, and other resources that can help project teams get organized and more effectively time their milestones. Some of the best project management tools for milestone tracking include Asana, ClickUp, monday work management, Smartsheet, and Wrike.

Adjust milestones as necessary

It’s rare that the initial milestones you set will encompass every change and issue that arises during the course of the project. That’s why project managers need to be agile, vigilant watchers of project performance data, KPIs, and any changes that happen within the internal team or on the client side. Noticing these changes before they become bigger issues is an important first step in communicating the need for and setting new milestones.

Project milestone examples

While this is not an exhaustive list, the following project milestone examples are often used to track project progress:

Start or end date of a project phase

Example: The project team has completed the discovery phase or solution verification period of pre-project research and planning. They have documented their plans through a project charter and received approval from the client to move forward with the actual project. This approval, illustrated in the Asana Gantt chart below, marks the achievement of their first project milestone.

In this milestone tracker example, the discovery phase milestone had to be completed before any project tasks could be started.
In this milestone tracker example, the discovery phase milestone had to be completed before any project tasks could be started. Source: Asana.

Completion of an initial product or key deliverable

Example: A digital marketing and design agency is helping a client rebrand in the new year. One of the milestones within that rebrand plan is to complete a refresh of the company’s web content, layout, and design. A project management tool like ClickUp helps users visualize the difference between this milestone and related tasks more easily with the Gantt chart layout.

An example of milestone tracking in ClickUp.
An example of milestone tracking in ClickUp. Source: ClickUp

Successful completion of user training

Example: A consulting firm is helping a small business set up a CRM solution that aligns with their customer data and outreach goals. Now that the software has been deployed, is integrated with their systems, and holds all of their relevant data, the project team must train the client’s marketing and sales teams on how to use the software. Achievement of the user training milestone may be determined by a skills test, a survey of trainees, or the completion of a specific training program.

FAQs

Using project milestones helps project teams stay on task and budget, focus on the most important steps of a project, allocate resources and time more efficiently, and tangibly track progress toward overarching project goals and KPIs.

Project milestones should be determined collaboratively by project managers and the stakeholders who have requested the project work. This collaboration ensures that milestones are achievable and match the wants and needs of the client.

Project milestones are measured with the help of KPIs as shown in project management software, analytics-driven dashboards, and regular progress reports.

The post What Are Project Milestones & How to Use Them appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
unnamed – 2024-07-22T210755.486 unnamed – 2024-07-22T210758.977
Top Paylocity Competitors & Alternatives for 2024 https://technologyadvice.com/blog/human-resources/paylocity-competitors/ Fri, 18 Aug 2023 21:23:12 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=111252 Whether you’re already a Paylocity user and looking for an upgrade or are just getting started in your HR software search, we’ve put together a list of Paylocity competitors to help you through the selection process: Take a look at our HR Software Guide to learn about other top HR and payroll software solutions. What […]

The post Top Paylocity Competitors & Alternatives for 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
Whether you’re already a Paylocity user and looking for an upgrade or are just getting started in your HR software search, we’ve put together a list of Paylocity competitors to help you through the selection process:

To put together this Paylocity alternatives guide, we assessed 15 different HR and payroll suites. Our assessment process included virtually chatting with customer service representatives, reading product documentation and pricing guides, and reading actual user reviews. We assessed these tools based on a number of criteria, including overall user experience, admin-level capabilities, appropriateness for businesses of different sizes, customer support quality, and scalability.

These are the solutions we assessed:

  • ADP Workforce Now.
  • RUN Powered by ADP.
  • Rippling HR Cloud.
  • BambooHR Platform.
  • TriNet Zenefits.
  • Workday HCM.
  • Paycom.
  • Gusto.
  • Namely.
  • Paychex Flex.
  • SAP SuccessFactors HXM.
  • UKG Pro.
  • Paycor.
  • Sage Core HR.
  • Homebase.

This product guide and its rankings may change, as we revisit and update our product guides on a regular basis. Our review process ensures readers have access to the latest industry and software information.

Take a look at our HR Software Guide to learn about other top HR and payroll software solutions.

What are the top Paylocity competitor?

Key differentiator Starting price Free trial?
RUN Powered by ADP Best for small businesses Contact vendor Yes Try RUN
Rippling Best for global workforce management $8/user/mo. Demo only Try Rippling
BambooHR Best for customer support and satisfaction Contact vendor Yes Try BambooHR
Workday HCM Best for analytics and reporting Contact vendor Demo only Try Workday
Paycom Best for employee self-service Contact vendor Demo only Try Paycom

RUN Powered by ADP: Best for small businesses

The ADP logo.

RUN Powered by ADP is a purpose-built HR and payroll solution for small businesses. It includes features for payroll, tax and compliance management, job posting, garnishments, employee handbook creation, employee training, and more.

In user reviews, customers have praised the solution’s overall ease of use, especially for automated tax filing and compliance support across all 50 U.S. states.

Learn more about RUN Powered by ADP →

User-friendly mobile app

The RUN Powered by ADP mobile app is one of ADP’s latest features and is already highly rated. Admin users can run payroll, build and review reports, add users, and access 24/7 support through the mobile app.

ADP's mobile app displays welcome page with summaries for upcoming payroll and to-dos.
Source: ADP
Tax filing and compliance support

Users benefit from automatic tax calculations and filing, as well as automatic updates when tax and compliance laws change. Other tax and compliance features include benefit and retirement deduction calculations, AI-powered error detection, W-2 and 1099 creation, and overtime alerts.

Relevant add-ons

For users who need more than what the four main RUN plans provide, a few different add-ons are available for integration. These add-ons address business needs such as business insurance, health benefits, retirement solutions, and time and scheduling.

ADP does not transparently list pricing information for any of its RUN Powered by ADP plans. However, some online user reviews indicate that pricing starts with a base of around $59 and an added $4 per employee per month. 

Four plans are available for RUN:

  • Essential Payroll
  • Enhanced Payroll
  • Complete Payroll & HR+
  • HR Pro Payroll & HR

ADP is also offering three months of free access to users who sign up for small business payroll processing. For the most accurate, up-to-date pricing information, prospective buyers will need to speak with an ADP representative directly.

RUN Powered by ADP is designed with a user-friendly interface and a clean admin dashboard view, making it a great fit for small businesses and organizations just getting started with this type of software. Tax and compliance features are built-in, comprehensive, and easy to use.

Additionally, RUN Powered by ADP supports automated payroll runs and provides step-by-step tips to admins as they run payroll.

Rippling: Best for global workforce management

The Rippling logo.

Rippling is a leading HRIS solution for businesses with globally distributed workforces. While many of its features are designed for midmarket and enterprise businesses that have larger global and remote teams, the platform also has features that work well for smaller businesses: PEO services, for example.

Customers have the option to sign up for any combination of Rippling’s modules they need, but all users must pay for access to Rippling’s base platform, Rippling Unity.

Learn more about Rippling →

Global payroll and workforce management

Global features are available that support payroll, benefits administration, and time and labor management in over 140 countries. Highlights of Rippling’s global capabilities include automated global tax filing, tailored benefits and worker policies, global analytics dashboards, and automated notifications for local wage, overtime, and leave requirements.

Rippling app displays global salaries converted to USD.
Source: Rippling
PEO services

Rippling offers professional employer organization HR administration and benefits features to organizations that don’t have in-house HR support. Services in this program include payroll runs, IT management, access to better health insurance plans, EPLI coverage, and pay-as-you-go workers’ comp insurance.

Talent management

Rippling’s talent management module can be used for recruiting, onboarding, and employee learning. Features include one-click job posting, custom hiring workflows, automated onboarding, and both pre-made and custom learning courses.

On Rippling’s pricing page, the company advertises that pricing starts at $8 per user per month. Customer reviews have indicated that this monthly price is accurate for certain HR Cloud modules, while others are more expensive. Regardless of what module(s) users select, they must also pay a base platform fee of approximately $35 to access Rippling Unity. 

Modules in the HR Cloud include:

  • US and Global Full-Service Payroll.
  • Time & Attendance.
  • Benefits Administration.
  • Flex Benefits: FSA, HSA & Commuter.
  • ACA & COBRA Administration.
  • Applicant Tracking.
  • Learning Management.
  • Pulse.
  • HR Help Desk: HR Support.
  • PEO Services.
  • Global Employer of Record Services.
  • Headcount Planning.
  • Compensation Bands.

Prospective buyers will need to request a quote directly from the Rippling team for more specific pricing information.

Though Rippling may not cover quite as many countries as Paylocity does with its global workforce management features, its features are more comprehensive and better suited to global teams’ unique needs.

Rippling particularly excels with its speedy global onboarding, localized compliance policies and administration, and unified reporting capabilities. Additionally, Rippling has more accessible customer service support and remote device management capabilities than Paylocity.

BambooHR: Best for customer support and satisfaction

The BambooHR logo.

BambooHR is an all-in-one HR suite with features that suit both small businesses and enterprises. The platform features tools for employee experience and performance management; payroll, time, and benefits management; hiring and onboarding; and data management and reporting.

Beyond these core features, users can also take advantage of the BambooHR Integration Marketplace, which connects the software to third-party communication and recruitment tools like Slack, Indeed, Checkr, and Greenhouse.

Learn more about BambooHR →

Reporting and analytics

BambooHR’s reporting and analytics tools are easy to use and come with a number of visualization and reporting options. Most notably, BambooHR comes with 49 built-in reports that users have reviewed favorably.

Source: BambooHR
Employee experience and performance management

Beyond traditional performance management features, BambooHR’s employee experience tools dive deep into overall employee satisfaction. Features include anonymous check-in surveys, eNPS scoring, and employee experience overview charts.

Onboarding and offboarding tools

BambooHR completely digitizes the onboarding and offboarding process with easy-to-use tools. Features include onboarding and new hire packet templates, built-in e-signature capabilities, compliant offboarding checklists, and turnover analytics.

BambooHR does not transparently discuss prices on its pricing page. The BambooHR Platform is available in two different plan options:

  • Essentials: Includes employee records, standard reporting, time-off management, mobile app access, employee self-service, and email support.
  • Advantage: Includes everything in the Essentials plan as well as onboarding and offboarding tools, applicant tracking system access, e-signatures, employee surveys, training tracking, customizable reports, phone and chat support, and open API access.

Users also have the option to pay for BambooHR’s add-on packages for payroll, benefits administration, performance management, and time tracking. Additionally, interested users can sign up for a free trial that gives them access to many BambooHR features. For specific pricing information, prospective buyers will need to request a price quote from the BambooHR team.

BambooHR is known for its strong customer support offerings and frequently receives glowing customer reviews in this area. The platform also has a stronger native applicant tracking system and more user-friendly employee experience tools than Paylocity does.

Workday HCM: Best for analytics and reporting

The Workday logo.

Workday HCM is a suite of human capital management solutions that is ideal for enterprises looking for comprehensive people management solutions. The platform includes some traditional HR software modules for human resource management and employee experience, but it goes beyond most SMB HR solutions to include case management, workforce planning, and ML-powered analytics.

Machine learning and intelligent automation are built into all corners of this solution, helping HR admins align talent with specific roles, augment analytics with contextual explanations, streamline payroll runs, and create smarter schedules for frontline employees.

Learn more about Workday HCM →

Augmented analytics

Workday People Analytics is an AI-augmented solution for understanding workforce data across diversity, retention, performance, hiring, and a variety of other organizational KPIs. The tool identifies anomalies, contextualizes data, and creates narratives to explain trends across different metrics.

Employee self-service

Workday’s native natural language processing (NLP) makes it so employees can ask questions and get helpful answers directly within and from the platform. Admins can boost employee self-service via case creation and status tracking.

Compensation management

This Workday HCM feature can be used to manage regular pay, bonuses, merit boosts, and other compensation formats in one place. Features include pay equity dashboards, compensation analysis tools, compensation program creation, and support for executive and sales incentive compensation.

Workday does not transparently discuss Workday HCM pricing on its website. User comments on exact Workday HCM costs vary, though nearly all user reviews mention that Workday HCM is an enterprise-level solution and one of the most expensive HRIS platforms on the market. Prospective buyers will need to contact Workday directly for specific pricing information.

Workday HCM provides advanced analytics, dashboards, and visualizations that outperform Paylocity and most other HRIS solutions in this area. Machine learning and intelligent automation are also built into a number of Workday HCM features, enhancing the software’s automated workflows and the depth of its reporting. Workday HCM is highly scalable and one of the best options for enterprise-level businesses.

Paycom: Best for employee self-service

Paycom is an online payroll and HR software solution that shares many feature similarities with Paylocity. However, it really sets itself apart from other solutions in this market with employee-first features that cover everything from payroll cards to an intuitive, mobile-friendly employee self-service portal.

Paycom works for businesses of all sizes and industrial backgrounds, but it has a particularly large presence among healthcare, finance, manufacturing, professional services, retail, and hospitality organizations.

Learn more about Paycom →

Payroll self-service

Paycom offers a number of self-service and unique payroll features that are ideal for employees in all kinds of roles, including hourly workers. Users can take advantage of Beti, everyday pay, and a company-provided payroll card; each of these features either expedites or otherwise simplifies the process of getting paid.

Source: Paycom
Other employee self-service features

Employees can manage and track various aspects of their work through the employee self-service portal, accessible via desktop or mobile app. Employees can request time off, clock in and out, enroll in benefits, submit receipts for reimbursement, track mileage, complete learning courses, and review their documents through the self-service portal.

Manager on-the-Go mobile app features

With the manager-centric mobile app, managers don’t need to login in order to handle various admin tasks on their mobile devices. Managers can view and update schedules, view job applications and resumes, move candidates through hiring processes, review and approve employee PTO, and review various employee demographic data.

Paycom does not transparently discuss its pricing plans on the Paycom website. Some user reviews have indicated that Paycom is priced with a custom base fee — dependent on how often your organization runs payroll — and then a per-employee-per-paycheck charge is added on top of that. Prospective buyers will need to contact Paycom directly for specific pricing information.

Paylocity includes a variety of features that focus on employee self-service and the employee user experience, including Beti for automated, DIY payroll; the Vault payroll card for quicker pay access; and the everyday pay option. Beyond its highly praised payroll and self-service features, Paycom also has a capable ATS solution and is generally considered easier to use than Paylocity.

What are the limitations of Paylocity?

Paylocity provides effective HR and payroll modules for businesses of all sizes, but its overall structure and approach to initial setup and training are not the best fit for everyone. If you’re trying to choose between Paylocity and other top HR management systems, keep these Paylocity limitations in mind during the selection process:

  • The implementation process is complex, especially for companies with many remote workers.
  • Setup isn’t cheap; users are required to pay a setup fee in addition to subscription access.
  • Hands-on training and technical support are limited for payroll/HR admins learning the software.
  • Though extensive integrations are available, many users have had difficulties setting up the integrations they need.
  • Somewhat limited global payroll capabilities are offered natively, though features are now available for over 100 countries.
  • The modular design sometimes requires double data entry across loosely connected modules.
  • The applicant tracking system functionality and customization opportunities are limited.
  • The employee self-service portal is somewhat complicated to use, and training materials are limited.

Choosing the right Paylocity alternative for your business

Paylocity is a well-rounded and highly-rated HR and payroll solution, but there are a number of alternatives that may be a better fit for your organization, depending on your specific requirements.

  • RUN Powered by ADP is a great choice if you’re operating in a small business and need easy-to-use, highly automated software
  • Rippling is your best bet if your organization is juggling compliance, payroll, and benefits for a global workforce.
  • BambooHR is a top selection if your team is less experienced with this type of software and wants reliable customer support throughout implementation and continued use.
  • Workday HCM is a good fit if you’re working in a larger business or enterprise and want detailed, customizable reporting tools.
  • Paycom is a top contender if you’re most interested in giving employees easy, hands-on access to their payroll and HR information.

If you’re still trying to decide if Paylocity or a different HR solution is the best fit for your business, check out our HR Software Guide for additional guidance.

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured HR software partners

Browse all HR software →

The post Top Paylocity Competitors & Alternatives for 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
ADP Figure B_ RUN ADP mobile app screenshot The Rippling logo. Rippling Figure-D-Rippling-Global-workforce-management-dashboard BambooHR BambooHR Reporting Analytics dashboard Workday Figure-H-Workday-HCM-augmented-analytics Figure I_ Paycom Logo Figure-J-Paycom-Beti
Best Workflow Automation Software 2024 https://technologyadvice.com/blog/project-management/best-workflow-automation-software/ Fri, 03 May 2024 18:13:49 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=52836 My top choices for the best workflow automation software solutions are the following: What are the best workflow automation software solutions? Star rating Starting price Workato 3.72/5 Custom pricing Visit Workato Zapier 3.52/5 $0 for up to 100 monthly tasks Visit Zapier UiPath 3.47/5 $0 for unlimited individual automation runs Visit UiPath Make 3.40/5 $0 […]

The post Best Workflow Automation Software 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
My top choices for the best workflow automation software solutions are the following:

  • Workato is best for enterprise security, admin, and support
  • Zapier is best for workflow building
  • UiPath is best for robotic process automation
  • Make is best for workflow maintenance
  • Pipefy is best for visual workflow editing
TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured partners

What are the best workflow automation software solutions?

Star rating Starting price
Workato 3.72/5 Custom pricing Visit Workato
Zapier 3.52/5 $0 for up to 100 monthly tasks Visit Zapier
UiPath 3.47/5 $0 for unlimited individual automation runs Visit UiPath
Make 3.40/5 $0 for up to 1,000 monthly operations Visit Make
Pipefy 3.03/5 $0 for up to five processes Visit Pipefy

May 3, 2024: Shelby Hiter rewrote the article to focus on workflow-specific software, which is why ClickUp, Jira, and Wrike no longer appear on this list. She then researched seven different platforms using an objective rubric, ultimately rewriting the article to focus on Workato, Zapier, UiPath, Make, and Pipefy as the top workflow automation software solutions. She also included in-depth information to explain the research and scoring methodology, as well as an updated final section about how to choose the best workflow automation software for your organization.

Our review is based on a rigorous scoring and evaluation methodology that focuses on the core features, capabilities, and other criteria that are most important to business users of workflow automation software. Before we began our actual scoring process, we looked at the overall workflow software market at a higher level, assessing more than 30 different software solutions across workflow automation, project management–specific workflow automation, and robotic process automation. 

From there, we were able to narrow our actual evaluation to seven leaders in the workflow automation market:

  • Zapier
  • Make
  • Kissflow
  • Workato
  • UiPath
  • Pipefy
  • Jitterbit

We evaluated all of these solutions based on seven broad categories of more than 50 subcriteria. Our research involved hands-on experience in each platform as well as thorough analysis of each vendor’s pricing and user reviews. Learn more about our core evaluation focus areas below.

Integrations: 25%

Our integration review process focused on the quantity, quality, and variety of integrations available to users since this is the most important aspect of any workflow automation software. The sheer volume of available prebuilt integrations was a large chunk of this score, but we also looked at the following:

  • Availability of webhooks or coding features for custom integrations.
  • Integrations for on-premises applications.
  • App connection sharing.
  • Allowlisting and app access restrictions.

Workflow building features: 20%

For the workflow building section of our assessment, we looked at several key factors that make the workflow design and implementation process run smoother for users of all backgrounds and skill levels. As far as accessibility goes, we paid close attention to:

  • No-code and drag-and-drop editing capabilities.
  • Quality and quantity of prebuilt recipes and project templates.
  • In-app notes and collaboration features.
  • AI-powered or RPA-powered assistance that supports more efficient and accurate builds.

We also looked for more advanced and powerful workflow-building features, including:

  • Conditional branching or simultaneous actions.
  • Custom forms.
  • Custom actions and triggers.
  • Custom fields.
  • Custom API calls.

Workflow maintenance features: 20%

In the workflow maintenance piece of our evaluation, we looked at the built-in tools available to support administrators and other users who want a real-time, comprehensive glimpse at how workflows are performing and what improvements need to be made. We most heavily emphasized robust usage analytics and dashboards, but we also looked for the ability to set up real-time error monitoring and alerts and detailed version history logs and databases.

Security and enterprise administrative features: 10%

Security and administrative features are hugely important to enterprises that need to manage highly sensitive data and applications within the platform. With this knowledge in mind, we scored each tool based on the following features:

  • User or group provisioning.
  • Audit logs.
  • Multifactor or two-factor authentication.
  • Role-based permissions and access control.
  • Single sign-on (SSO).
  • API proxies.
  • IP whitelisting.

At a user level, we looked at whether these tools allow guests and external users, and if so, how these users and their access are managed. We also considered how shared workspaces and project folders are organized and managed. Finally, we looked into each vendor’s security certifications and other security and privacy commitments to determine how well they would handle stricter compliance requirements.

Pricing: 10%

For pricing, we considered first and foremost how much value this product provides to its users across subscription tiers. We also assessed the overall scalability of each tool and the quality of their free subscription tiers, where applicable. Some vendors were unable to be direct with their pricing information, due to what they call an entirely tailored pricing structure that follows a case-by-case basis. In some instances, these vendors were docked due to the lack of pricing transparency.

Support: 10%

In this portion of our evaluation, we assessed the overall quality, usability, and availability of customer support. We looked at:

  • Support hours.
  • Multichannel support options (phone, email, ticketing, and/or chat).
  • Self-service resources.
  • Live training sessions.
  • Community forums.
  • Knowledge base articles.

User reviews: 5%

For the user review criteria, we researched how well each software solution was reviewed across third-party review sites. The sites we focused on include TrustRadius, Capterra, G2, and Gartner Peer Insights. 

Workato: Best for enterprise security, admin, and support


Pros

  • Excellent customer support
  • Enterprise-level scalability and features

Cons

  • No pricing transparency and no free plan
  • SDK development work may be necessary for certain customizations.
Workato logo.

Our Rating: 3.72/5

  • Overall: 3.72
  • User scores: 4.63
  • Pricing: 1.25
  • Support: 4.56
  • Integrations: 3.81
  • Workflow building: 3.63
  • Workflow maintenance: 4.13
  • Security and administration: 4.06

Workato is a leading enterprise workflow automation solution that is designed to support intelligent process automation for a variety of applications and use cases. The platform has more than 1,000 prebuilt integrations, public and private sharing options for connectors, various AI connectors and support tools, custom app connector options, and plenty of resources for on-premises workflows and apps.

Workato offers enterprise governance, security, and administrative features, which include high-quality audit logs, role-based access control, real-time monitoring, and usage analytics.

The tool also takes a collaborative approach, offering the Collaborators feature for human user management, API client management, and workplace management. With the Workato platform, users can effectively customize automation recipes and collaborate through in-app notes and comments on recipe steps.

Multichannel customer support is also available 24/7, which comes with unique support options like Product Hour presentations on various topics.

Workato’s biggest weakness is its lack of pricing transparency. However, although Workato is not very transparent with the actual numbers for its subscription prices, the plans themselves seem to be great for growing companies and use cases. Unlimited app and data connectivity, unlimited connections and recipes, unlimited builders and administrators, and other advanced features are included in all plans. Volume discounts are also available, particularly for users who use more than 1 million tasks, which is the minimum.

Custom and community connectors

Although Workato has an extensive collection of prebuilt connectors, it gives users access to a wide range of resources and tools to help them build their own. Depending on the design they choose, users can either share these custom connectors only within their organization’s workspace, or they can publicly share it with the Workato community.

With community connectors, Workato customers can easily learn more about the custom connector and its builder, its source code, what else has been built by that builder, and version history for that connector.

Workato's connector page for BigCommerce.
Any Workato user can build custom connectors. From there, they can opt to publicly share their connectors, as the organization above has done, or they can share it privately within their workspace. Source: Workato.
Role-based access control

Role-based access controls are both easy to use and highly customizable in Workato workspaces. For smaller companies or those that want to keep things simple, sticking with Workato’s three predefined roles—admin, analyst, and operator—might work better.

However, most organizations opt to create custom roles, which can be set up with highly granular permission sets across different tools and features for recipe development, platform tools, and admin privileges. These roles can be designated based on hierarchy, department or core responsibilities, or employee type.

Permissions range from full access to editing privileges to view-only privileges to no privileges at all. As your team grows and changes, roles can be cloned, deleted, and otherwise modified.

Workato's admin control panel for role-based access permissions.
When a new user is added to your Workato account, the user type you select will come with predetermined access options that you can adjust as needed. These access categories cover recipe, platform, and admin access, and access levels range from full admin access to editing privileges to view only to no access at all. Source: Workato.

Workato does not disclose exact pricing details unless the user goes through the product demo and sales process, as prices are tailored to the exact needs of each customer. Business users must first select their preferred workspace and add tasks. Task count starts at 1 million, and volume discounts may be available for larger operations. Pricing may also look different for users who are interested in embedding Workato functionality directly into one of their products.

Hoping to get a little more information about how pricing works, I reached out to Workato’s support team and received the following response from an inbound SDR on their team: 

“To keep it simple, there are two components to our pricing. The first is our annual platform fee. This includes unlimited users on our platform and access to over 2,000 pre-built connectors.

The second component is consumption-based. This increases as you add additional apps/workflows.

Because the price is so tailored to how our prospects decide to use it, we encourage them to take a scoping call where we can really delve into what they’re looking to do and then provide pricing from there.”

While this response did not provide me with much more additional detail, the representative responded to my query very quickly and thoroughly, which was appreciated.

I chose Workato because it’s a well-rounded and highly praised workflow solution that can handle enterprise-level automation needs.

The platform has received great user reviews, with some especially highlighting the quality of Workato’s customer support. Unlike most vendors in this space, Workato offers 24/7 support to all customers, with phone support and live chat as options. My own interactions with the Workato customer service team were prompt and thorough, even though I was not a subscribed user. 

During my research, I found that Workato also had the most consistent and comprehensive security and admin features for its users. Top-tier audit logs, SSO, RBAC, and other enterprise security features are available; 2FA and just in time (JIT) provisioning are key parts of all plans; and extensive data compliance certifications are touted on the Workato website as a core part of their approach and architecture.

Combining these features with unique value-adds like the AI@Work suite of solutions, unlimited connections and recipes, unlimited builders and administrators, and tools to support on-premise applications and integrations, Workato can handle different types of workflow automation projects and support the needs of users with varying skill levels.

Zapier: Best for workflow building


Pros

  • 6,000+ integrations available; more than nearly all competitors
  • High levels of customizability in all tiers and at all skill levels

Cons

  • Lacking usage analytics capabilities
  • Limited security and admin features in lower tiers
Zapier logo.

Our Rating: 3.52/5

  • Overall: 3.52
  • User scores: 4.61
  • Pricing: 3.75
  • Support: 3.44
  • Integrations: 3.50
  • Workflow building: 4.75
  • Workflow maintenance: 2.50
  • Security and administration: 2.50

Zapier is one of the most popular workflow automation software solutions on the market—and for good reason. With more than 6,000 prebuilt app integrations and a variety of custom actions, triggers, and fields, Zapier’s scalability for nearly any business use case feels limitless.

Beyond its integration options and capabilities, Zapier stands apart from the crowd most when it comes to workflow-building features. Its automation templates and recipes are extensive, diverse, and available in all plans. The no-code workflow builder and visual editor are easy to use, even for users who have never worked with this type of software before. And the depth of customizable features, in-app collaboration capabilities, and AI-powered automations help this tool to scale as your team’s goals evolve.

In addition to more conventional workflow automation features, users can also benefit from multi-step actions and processing, version histories, and 2FA in all plans.

AI automations

A significant chunk of Zapier’s more than 6,000 prebuilt integrations and applications are AI-based, focusing on popular tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, Anthropic’s Claude, and Synthesia, among others. This unique capability allows users to set up workflows with their most-used AI tools and other business applications, which is particularly helpful for content generation and process management tasks that can benefit from a user not toggling between two different applications constantly.

In addition to these AI app connectors, Zapier also supports AI-powered automation via AI power-ups, AI-supported coding steps, and custom actions powered by AI. All of these AI automation features are available in all plans, including the free tier.

Zapier's catalog of artificial intelligence apps, including ChatGPT, OpenAI, and Fathom.
A total of 195 different AI-focused apps are set up to work smoothly with Zapier workflow automation builds. Source: Shelby Hiter via Zapier.
In-app collaboration and customizations

In-app collaboration is easy in Zapier. As you can see below, basic collaboration and communication are as simple as adding a note to any step in a workflow. Depending on the plan, Zapier users can also manage teams, organize projects into folders, share Zaps, and share app connections with other users.

All of these sharing capabilities are especially useful when taking advantage of Zapier’s high levels of customization. Users can collaborate on and make adjustments to custom actions, custom fields, and custom API calls in all Zapier plans.

Zapier's visual editor for a zap with steps for Gmail and monday.com.
In my Zapier account, it was very easy to figure out how I could write and share notes with other users on any trigger or task. Source: Shelby Hiter via Zapier

  • Free: $0 for 100 tasks per month and access to Zaps, Interfaces (Basic), and Tables (Basic)
  • Professional: Starts at $19.99 per month, billed annually, or $29.99 billed monthly. This plan requires users to sign up for at least 750 monthly tasks and goes up to 2 million monthly tasks (which costs $3,389 per month, billed annually, or $5,099 billed monthly). Custom limits beyond 2 million are available for interested users who contact the sales team.
  • Team: Starts at $69 per month, billed annually, or $103.50 billed monthly. This plan requires users to sign up for at least 2,000 monthly tasks and goes up to 2 million monthly tasks (which costs $3,999 per month, billed annually, or $5,999 billed monthly). Custom limits beyond 2 million are available for interested users who contact the sales team.
  • Enterprise: Pricing information is only available upon request. This plan version includes advanced admin and security features as well as more comprehensive customer support resources.

Zapier proved to be a reasonably priced and scalable workflow automation solution, though many features that may be necessary for teams managing corporate or sensitive data are only available in the highest product tiers. Additionally, users who go over their monthly task limits will be charged 1.5x more per each additional task needed in that billing period, which can quickly become expensive. 

However, Zapier provides users with a generous free plan and is incredibly scalable, especially with the range of features already available in the lower-tier plans. Each plan tier offers reasonable upgrades with minimal upcharges from tier to tier.

I chose Zapier because it is a highly scalable solution that provides incredible prebuilt workflow integration options and customizability, meaning it will work for users of all skill levels and backgrounds.

Zapier far outpaces its competitors in the realm of prebuilt integrations, offering more than 6,000 options including modern AI applications like ChatGPT. Zapier keeps its catalog relevant and up-to-date, so even as business applications evolve and change over time, Zapier has the tools necessary to automate new workflows.

Although the free tier is limited to only one user, the features that the user can access are solid. I was impressed by my ability to access unlimited zaps and connections, automation templates and recipes, and AI power-ups and actions in my free account. Custom actions, triggers, fields, and API calls are also possible in all plans. However, additional points were docked for a pretty severe lack of useful analytics in the tool.

Zapier has received some of the best reviews in this sector, with reviewers frequently commenting on its ease of use and versatility. Its workflow-building tools are some of the best available, and what’s more, almost all of its workflow-building tools and capabilities are available in all plans. While some of the features can get a little overwhelming, I still had a fairly easy time setting up integrations that made sense in my free account.

UiPath: Best for robotic process automation


Pros

  • Process and task mining for enterprise users
  • Comprehensive automation tracking and management features, primarily through Orchestrator

Cons

  • Limited number of prebuilt integrations and apps
  • No 2FA or MFA access management capabilities
UiPath logo.

Our Rating: 3.47/5

  • Overall: 3.47
  • User scores: 4.38
  • Pricing: 3.56
  • Support: 3.81
  • Integrations: 3.44
  • Workflow building: 3.38
  • Workflow maintenance: 3.50
  • Security and administration: 2.81

UiPath is a robotic process automation and workflow automation tool that takes a unique, more hands-off approach to workflow automation. With the help of both attended and unattended robots, users can set up workflow automations for a variety of business cases. Tools like the built-in Orchestrator, Data Service, Test Manager, AI Center, and Insights all help users to deploy, monitor, manage, and update robotic workflows over time.

For teams that want to combine RPA with human-powered workflow automation, UiPath offers features to support this as well. For example, the platform has an Action Center, which is specifically designed to facilitate handoffs between robots and humans.

UiPath can work for either small, low-budget teams or high-powered enterprises, depending on which plan you select. For enterprises, on-premises solutions, process and task mining, multitenancy, and more advanced robots are all available to optimize UiPath’s capabilities.

Orchestrator for automation management

Orchestrator is UiPath’s primary automation management tool that can be used to manage the actions and work history of both attended and unattended robots. Even at an enterprise level, users can automate and monitor robotic automations, manage queues and assets, reference storage buckets and performance analytics, and take other steps to provision and deploy RPA. Regardless of which plan you select, Orchestrator is the ideal UiPath space for managing webhooks, custom connectors, parallel processes, and version history.

UiPath's dashboard showing a summary of jobs statuses and histories.
Even from my free UiPath account, I can access Orchestrator, which offers detailed information about how robotic automations have run and are currently running. Source: Shelby Hiter via UiPath.
Robotic process automation

Depending on the plan you’re in, you can access attended robots, unattended robots, automation cloud robots, and test robots for more specific and complex automation projects.

Attended or supervised robots are available in all plans, including the free one. Unattended robots are available in all paid plans, allowing users to establish unattended robots that can automate workflows without much human intervention. Test robots are available in UiPath’s top two tiers.

These robots are great for enterprises that want a full lifecycle management process that can be monitored and tested before deploying into production.

UiPath's attended robot displays a list of processes for tasks like scheduling a meeting, requesting time off, and analyzing data.
With attended robots, available in all UiPath plans, users can set up hands-off automations for a variety of business tasks. Source: UiPath.

  • Free: $0 for unlimited individual automation runs and limited access to other UiPath features
  • Pro: Starts at $420 per month
  • Enterprise: Pricing information available upon request

Additionally, there is the Pro Trial signup option, which includes more features than the Pro plan but fewer than the Enterprise plan.

I chose UiPath because it provides all of the conventional workflow automation features you’d expect from this type of tool but with helpful additions in the form of RPA. It also provides process and task mining capabilities in higher-tier plans, which enables a greater-than-normal ability to get down into the details of your tasks and optimize them. 

Even with my free plan, I was able to take advantage of the Orchestrator tool and can say that it is a powerful assistant to its users, helping them to comprehensively visualize performance and manage both human-run and robot-run automations. The analytics in this section of the tool are impressive, getting down into usage details and into more specific information about assets, storage, and other factors that could impact workflow automation performance and longevity. 

The only area that was somewhat lacking was the free plan, as it did not include any real access to customer support resources. I found myself circling through the platform, trying to find any way to get in touch with the support team for simple questions, but this proved ineffective.

While this certainly docked UiPath’s overall score, the free plan still has many redeeming and useful qualities. Webhooks and custom connectors are available in all plans, the capable Integration Service is fully available to all users, and comprehensive security and admin features like RBAC and audit logs are part of every plan.

In my personal opinion, this tool is a little overwhelming for inexperienced or less-technical users, but for the right team and skill sets, UiPath is one of the best options for the utmost scalability.

Make: Best for workflow maintenance


Pros

  • Comprehensive tools for monitoring and managing workflow automation performance
  • Unlimited users in free plan with generous automation quantities at each plan level

Cons

  • Limited customer support resources outside of enterprise tier plans
  • Customizations are limited in lower-tier plans
Make logo.

Our Rating: 3.40/5

  • Overall: 3.40
  • User scores: 4.73
  • Pricing: 3.94
  • Support: 2.00
  • Integrations: 2.81
  • Workflow building: 3.19
  • Workflow maintenance: 4.88
  • Security and administration: 2.50

Make, formerly known as Integromat, is a workflow automation and workflow management solution that helps users design custom workflows for a variety of apps and business projects. Make is best known for its user-friendly, no-code interface as well as its array of workflow maintenance solutions. 

Users are particularly impressed with Make’s real-time error monitoring and alerts, parallel scenario execution, and version history features, which are each available in all plan tiers, including the free plan. Users also appreciate Make’s approach to usage analytics, with a My Organization dashboard that includes multiple tabs to look at different kinds of metrics.

Make is an all-around solution for workflow lifecycle management and automation, and it works well for users who want a collaborative platform for unlimited users. The company also frequently updates the tool and sources feedback from its users to improve its offerings.

Usage analytics

For a platform that is otherwise fairly simple compared to competitors, Make provides users with one of the most detailed and useful organizational dashboards for usage analytics. In the My Organization section of the Make platform, users can toggle between tabs for organization, teams, users, subscription, payments, installed apps, variables, and scenario properties data. The organization section is particularly straightforward and useful, giving users clear information about their current subscription tier, active scenarios, percentage of operations used, and percentage of data transfers used, among others.

Make's organizational dashboard displays a line graph for operations and data transfer utilization.
Although I had not yet set up any scenarios, I could very easily find information about what work I had done and how close I was to reaching my free plan usage limit. Source: Shelby Hiter via Make.
Webhooks

Webhooks are available and easy to set up regardless of which Make subscription plan you select. The interface for webhooks integrations is highly visual, not only showing the connections that are in place via a diagram but also providing information about operations history, any incomplete executions from past operations, and which operations are currently running. All users have the option to execute simultaneous operations and processes through webhooks.

Make displays a panel of multiple webhook triggers running simultaneously.
In this scenario demonstration, which was built through webhooks, all instant webhooks run and process actions simultaneously. Source: Make.

  • Free: $0 for unlimited users to use up to 1,000 operations per month
  • Core: Starts at $9 per month, billed annually, for 10,000 ops per month, or $10.59 billed monthly for the same number of ops. This plan’s pricing raises in intervals based on how many monthly operations you require. It can go up to 2 million ops per month, which would cost $988.28 if billed annually or $1,162.68 if billed monthly. A higher number of monthly operations may be available upon request.
  • Pro: Starts at $16 per month, billed annually, for 10,000 ops per month, or $18.24 billed monthly for the same number of ops. This plan’s pricing raises in intervals based on how many monthly operations you require. It can go up to 2 million ops per month, which would cost $1,377.67 if billed annually or $1,620.79 if billed monthly. A higher number of monthly operations may be available upon request.
  • Teams: Starts at $29 per month, billed annually, for 10,000 ops per month, or $34.12 billed monthly for the same number of ops. This plan’s pricing raises in intervals based on how many monthly operations you require. It can go up to 8 million ops per month, which would cost $8,231.05 if billed annually or $9,683.59 if billed monthly. A higher number of monthly operations may be available upon request.
  • Enterprise: Pricing information available upon request for 24/7 customer support. This plan includes more advanced security and admin features and other unique enterprise-level features.

I chose Make because it is one of the best workflow automation deals on the market, especially for free plan users.

The free plan supports unlimited users and 1,000 automation operations per month. This makes the tool a great choice for a larger team that wants to experiment with their options, or even for a startup that has just begun setting up enterprise workflows.

With access to 1,739 prebuilt integrations, universally available webhooks, and great conditional branching and logic, this tool works well for teams that need to build complex integration and workflow structures for their business.

Make’s workflow maintenance features are truly some of the best today, with users frequently praising the quality of its error monitoring and alerts features as well as its AI assistant (currently in Beta) and its usage analytics. I was particularly impressed with the My Organization dashboard; even in my free-tier subscription, I was able to easily review a variety of data points like system-wide usage and performance, installed apps, variables, and scenario properties.

From where I sit, Make seems to be progressing and advancing its tool quickly and in a direction that will be favorable for businesses that care about digital transformation. With its AI assistant already working well in Beta, its recent replacement of the legacy Integromat, and the company’s commitment to crowdsourcing feedback from users, I expect this platform will continue to improve and rise through the ranks.

Pipefy: Best for visual workflow editing


Pros

  • Special plan and discount system for small businesses
  • Highly visual, project-management-style workflow management interface

Cons

  • Several workflow building and customization features are actually offered through Workato, not Pipefy directly
  • Incredibly limited free plan features
Pipefy logo.

Our Rating: 3.03/5

  • Overall: 3.03
  • User scores: 4.38
  • Pricing: 3.63
  • Support: 3.44
  • Integrations: 1.75
  • Workflow building: 4.19
  • Workflow maintenance: 2.75
  • Security and administration: 2.75

Pipefy is a workflow and business process automation solution that focuses on form just as much as function. The platform is designed with a Kanban interface—very similar to Trello—so each card and subfield can be quickly visualized and customized to meet project demands. The platform is filled with prebuilt templates and forms, divided by industry and use case, allowing users of all backgrounds to quickly build workflows even with no experience.

This platform is designed for businesses of all sizes, but it’s important to note that the free plan is incredibly limited. While working with my own free account, I ran out of space almost immediately and before I had actually built a true workflow. Keep this in mind if you’re operating on a strict budget, though most user reviews indicate that lower-tier paid plans are reasonably priced.

Standout features in Pipefy include a customer success manager for all paid plan subscribers, guest and external user access, unlimited users in all paid plans, an AI copilot, and a shared workspace on all tiers. For the shared workspace, there does not seem to be a way to share notes with other users, which may inhibit in-app collaboration. However, RBAC and pipe settings make it so you can granularly adjust each card in each pipe. The email settings may also make it so you can send notes and notifications to users, though external to the platform.

Kanban view

Similar to many of the most popular project management software solutions and platforms, Pipefy improves its user interface with visual project views like the Kanban view. This view helps users to easily get an overarching view of how their workflows are progressing, where any bottlenecks may be developing, and where additional details about deadlines or stakeholders may need to be added.

Pipefy’s Kanban view is incredibly customizable, with options to set up custom fields and task information. Users can also easily drag and drop project components and edit from the Kanban view with no coding or developer actions required.

Pipefy displays a Kanban board with workflows in various project stages.
For lovers of Kanban-style project management, the Pipefy project board is a great fit. Source: Shelby Hiter via Pipefy.
Project templates

Pipefy’s template gallery includes a mixture of project templates for easier workflow and form setup. The primary categories for templates cover business operations, finance, human resources, IT, and procurement. Within those categories, users can find highly detailed templates that focus on common use cases like sales pipelines, accounts payable, recruitment and hiring, customer support and help desk workflows, and more. These templates not only give users a basic skeleton to work with but also include tasks, subtasks, and other granular details that can help teams build out comprehensive, detailed processes with little to no experience with workflow management.

Pipefy's library of workflow templates.
Even as a free plan user, I was able to access a pretty impressive array of business- and industry-specific workflow templates. Source: Shelby Hiter via Pipefy.

  • Starter: $0 for up to 10 users to access up to five processes and other limited features
  • Business: Pricing information only available upon request. This plan includes unlimited users, unlimited processes, and other more advanced features.
  • Enterprise: Pricing information only available upon request. This plan includes integrations, multiple automations, and more advanced security and admin capabilities.
  • Unlimited: Pricing information only available upon request. This plan includes unlimited automations, unlimited data storage, and other enterprise-level features.
  • Special Plan for Small Businesses: Qualified businesses with 11 to 200 employees can access all product features at a 90% discount, presumably discounted from the typical cost of the Unlimited plan.

I chose Pipefy for this list because it is an incredibly approachable workflow automation solution.

Its Kanban interface is key here, making it so users don’t have to know how to code or connect their workflows to make them work. If you have a basic grasp of how you want your processes to run or even if you’ve used a PM platform like Trello, Pipefy will help you build the “pipes,” custom cards, and subfields necessary to create an effective workflow automation setup.

I also selected this tool because, unlike many other workflow automation platforms that focus solely on enterprise needs and budgets, Pipefy does a great job of creating unique value-adds for smaller businesses and teams. I was especially drawn in by the tool’s special plan for small businesses, which gives eligible companies up to a 90% discount on enterprise-level features.

I also appreciate the company’s weekly office hours approach that makes customer service more accessible to all and their commitment to providing all paid plan users with a dedicated customer success manager.

Finally, I selected Pipefy over many other leaders in this field because of its strategy for guest and external access. It is one of the few platforms that effectively support administrators with an easy way to add both company guests and external guests, who can have forms shared with them regardless of the plan you select.

How to choose the best workflow automation software for your business

While we recommend all the workflow software solutions above, the best one for your business depends on your unique situation. When deciding on what tool to use, it is important that you know what you need. Whether you’re looking to develop hands-off automations through RPA or simple workflows to improve your marketing and CRM setup, different tools are available to address these use cases and more.

Based on our evaluations, these are the best tools to choose for the following situations:

  • Choose Workato if you want an enterprise-grade, scalable solution that comes with all the bells and whistles, particularly for security, administrative, and support features.
  • Select Zapier if your top priority is a large and diverse library of prebuilt connectors and workflow-building tools that are both customizable and user-friendly.
  • Opt for UiPath if you’re interested in developing more complex automation cadences through RPA or process and task mining, in addition to more traditional workflow automations.
  • Pick Make if you’re looking for a generous free subscription tier that scales well without compromising on usability, particularly for workflow maintenance.
  • Go with Pipefy if a project-management-style interface—with extensive templates and prebuilt forms to choose from—is most important to you.

If you don’t see the right workflow automation software for your business in our picks above, check out more options in our business process management and project management software guides.

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured project management partners

Browse all project management software →

The post Best Workflow Automation Software 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
workato Workato connector page Any Workato user can build custom connectors. From there, they can opt to publicly share their connectors, as the organization above has done, or they can share it privately within their workspace. Source: Workato. Workato admin control panel When a new user is added to your Workato account, the user type you select will come with predetermined access options that you can adjust as needed. These access categories cover recipe, platform, and admin access, and access levels range from full admin access to editing privileges to view only to no access at all. Source: Workato. zapier-svg Zapier catalog A total of 195 different AI-focused apps are set up to work smoothly with Zapier workflow automation builds. Source: Shelby Hiter via Zapier. Zapier visual editor In my Zapier account, it was very easy to figure out how I could write and share notes with other users on any trigger or task. Source: Shelby Hiter via Zapier uipath logo uipath dashboard Even from my free UiPath account, I can access Orchestrator, which offers detailed information about how robotic automations have run and are currently running. Source: Shelby Hiter via UiPath. uipath attended robot With attended robots, available in all UiPath plans, users can set up hands-off automations for a variety of business tasks. Source: UiPath. make make organizational dashboard Although I had not yet set up any scenarios, I could very easily find information about what work I had done and how close I was to reaching my free plan usage limit. Source: Shelby Hiter via Make. make panel In this scenario demonstration, which was built through webhooks, all instant webhooks run and process actions simultaneously. Source: Make. pipefy pipefy kanban board For lovers of Kanban-style project management, the Pipefy project board is a great fit. Source: Shelby Hiter via Pipefy. pipefy library Even as a free plan user, I was able to access a pretty impressive array of business- and industry-specific workflow templates. Source: Shelby Hiter via Pipefy.
Succession Planning Examples https://technologyadvice.com/blog/human-resources/succession-planning-examples/ Mon, 08 Apr 2024 12:19:00 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=61921 Considering succession planning for your business? Learn from the best examples of succession planning across multiple companies & industries in 2024.

The post Succession Planning Examples appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>

Key takeaways

  • Succession planning is the act of developing long- and short-term strategies to fill critical roles when they become vacant.
  • Both SMBs and enterprise organizations need effective succession plans to maintain business continuity during organizational changes.
  • Formalized training and development programs prepare emerging leaders to step into leadership positions when the time comes.
  • Apr. 8, 2024: Shelby Hiter restructured the content for improved readability, expanded the definition of succession planning, and provided additional examples of succession planning in a SMB context. She also added information about the requirements and best practices for effective succession planning.

Top succession planning examples

Because there are so many different scenarios for which succession planning is necessary, it can be difficult to know the best way to approach succession planning for your organization. Most succession plans generally fall into one of three categories: long-term/target-date plans, training-based plans, and situational/emergency plans.

Check out our video overview below:

Long-term succession planning

Long-term succession planning focuses on identifying and preparing someone for a role long before it is actually open.

Because of the gradual training that goes into this type of succession planning, it primarily focuses on developing and promoting individuals from within the existing ranks. In many cases, this type of succession planning begins with hiring someone for a role that comes with well-defined opportunities for advancement.

Sometimes, long-term succession planning is motivated by a clear timeframe for a position’s vacancy. For example, if you know your CEO is planning to retire in two years, you know exactly how long you have to identify and develop their successor.

In most cases, though, long-term succession planning does not have a firm deadline; the strategy is in place to provide an onramp for the next leader to step into each role with as little disruption as possible.

Requirements for long-term succession planning

For long-term succession planning to be successful, business leaders must recognize, train, and nurture high performers over time to set them and the organization up for success. That way, when the opportunity arises to take on a key role, that individual is well prepared to assume their new responsibilities.

This strategy takes time, but it’s much easier the sooner a company recognizes the potential of high-performing employees and implements development pathways. Long-term succession planning requires a number of ingredients that maximize employee retention:

  • A supportive company culture with competitive benefits.
  • Performance and talent management tools that help managers identify top internal talent early on.
  • Robust learning and development programs that are personalized to employees’ goals and strengths.
  • Regular transparent communications and performance reviews that give high performers a chance to receive feedback and learn more about the organization’s plans for them.
  • If no internal candidates make sense for the role, HR and recruitment teams will need to spend time defining the role’s key responsibilities and completing outreach efforts with eligible candidates.
  • A succession plan template may also be a helpful tool to keep your long-term plans organized, even as other organizational variables change.

Though it requires sustained effort, long-term succession planning is more effective than getting caught off guard by someone leaving and scrambling to train an employee to take their place.

Long-term succession plan example

The CEO of your organization has announced to the rest of their leadership team that they plan to retire in four years when they turn 65. Before this announcement, the CEO has already documented their responsibilities, their preferred successor(s), important points of contact, and any other information the organization may need to manage change across the organization and with client relationships.

Ideally, the CEO’s preferred successor has already started receiving mentorship and guidance to prepare them for the role. Your HR team uses the succession plan to identify additional development opportunities and works with the successor to create a four-year plan that will enable a smooth transition.

As a fail safe, the succession plan also clarifies if and when the talent acquisition team should start reviewing external candidates for the role. If it becomes clear the tentative successor isn’t right for the role, a list of backup options ensures the company’s sustained success regardless of who ultimately takes over as CEO.

Use our complete guide to employee development plans and free template download to get started!

Training-based succession planning

Your learning and development or HR team can create an internal educational academy or e-learning program, complete with a curriculum that trains and develops employees as future leaders in the company. This kind of formal training accelerates employees’ progress toward professional goals and helps them prepare to advance in their roles once they complete the training. 

Formalized, training-based succession planning also supports diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) efforts by helping employees get promoted into leadership roles based on merit and a demonstrated commitment to growth and development. Without a structured training program in place, managers’ biases may cause them to choose successors based on who’s a longstanding or favored member of their team rather than who is most qualified.

Training employees across teams and experience levels provides more employees with a chance to progress in their career trajectory — not just those employees who work closest to the C-suite. Ultimately, this strategy increases the pool of quality candidates to build a pipeline for important roles.

Requirements for training-based succession planning

To successfully implement an education-based succession planning program, it’s important to do the following:

  • Create a training program that balances general leadership and more specialized skills.
  • Give all employees an equal opportunity to access training and development opportunities.
  • Incorporate regular assessments and performance reviews into the training cycle.
  • Ensure training and certification programs are included as milestones in your role-banding and promotional paths.
  • Invest in a learning management system (LMS) that allows employees to take charge of their own growth opportunities.

Also read: LMS Features You Need for a Great E-Learning Program

Training-based succession plan example

Your small B2B technology marketing agency has traditionally focused on digital marketing campaigns and content strategy, but your leadership team wants to establish an additional revenue stream by developing a proprietary software product. Many members of your team know this market well but don’t have direct product development, marketing, or sales experience.

Instead of creating an entire team of net-new hires to support this new business initiative, your leadership team has decided to start an internal training program to prepare selected individuals to transition to product team roles, including:

  • Product designer.
  • Product strategist.
  • Product marketing specialist.
  • Product account executive.

With this training program, internal members of your team are given an exciting opportunity to learn new skills, advance their careers, and use their institutional knowledge to help onboard other product team members.

Situational or emergency succession planning

Not all role and leadership transitions can be planned: An important executive may suddenly need to take an extended leave of absence for medical or family reasons. A CEO may suddenly choose to or be asked to step down for the good of the company. A new federal or industry regulation may require you to bring on a compliance management professional on short notice.

In these types of scenarios, an emergency succession plan is the best way to stabilize your company through the turbulence.

Both situational and long-term succession plans acknowledge the fact that every person at the company will leave their roles eventually; the difference is that a situational succession plan is a contingency if the details of when and how someone exits diverge from the original plan.

Requirements for situational or emergency succession planning

Because this type of succession planning is rooted in the unknown, it’s impossible to prepare for every possible scenario. Like all good contingency plans, however, preparation involves identifying key figures at a high level and defining an order of operations that can go into effect automatically:

  • Identify the roles that are critical to business operations — CEOs, VPs, department heads, etc. — and document each role’s core responsibilities and job functions.
  • Determine which individuals or groups are most equipped to cover each responsibility short-term, and provide training/resources as needed.
  • Assemble an emergency response team who will coordinate to find a long-term solution.
  • Prepare detailed documentation that references other emergency response plans for health and safety, public relations, client relations, etc.

Emergency succession plan example

Your organization’s marketing director has suddenly become ill and needs to take a leave of absence for a couple of weeks to recover. The emergency succession plan outlines their core responsibilities, such as approving budgets, reporting departmental performance to the CEO, and supervising team leads.

The plan also identifies who should cover these duties while they’re away: the finance director coordinates budget approvals, the SEO team lead prepares departmental reports for the CEO, the HR manager sets up regular staff check-ins to address administrative needs, and other essential responsibilities are distributed across the team.

There are also specifications for other variables, like hiring an interim replacement if the director’s medical leave is extended or consulting an external firm about high-level marketing strategy changes.

Succession planning FAQs

Succession planning is the process of ensuring that critical positions — especially those that are highly specialized and further up the ladder — are always staffed. It’s a change management strategy that involves identifying the unique requirements for each essential role and proactively upskilling employees so they’re ready to advance when the time is right.

Forward-thinking succession planning is essential to sustained growth, business continuity, risk management, employee engagement, and retention efforts. However, as companies strategically train employees for future roles, managers need to ensure that employees receive the active support they require to avoid employee burnout.

Depending on the type of succession plan you implement and the goals you have in mind, many people will play a role in succession planning for your organization:

  • Executive leaders.
  • HR teams.
  • Learning and development teams.
  • Individual managers.
  • Third-party consultants.

Companies need to take inevitable turnover into account and have a succession plan in place to keep critical roles filled. A succession plan can help maintain growth and stability as well as encourage retention and career development for motivated employees.

Succession planning prepares the company for the loss of key personnel in a strategic and scalable way. The benefits of this preparation include:

  • Business resilience no matter the economic climate.
  • Continued operations with minimal downtime or transitional hiccups.
  • Equitable workloads, so other employees aren’t overburdened by taking over additional tasks as a result of a vacancy.
  • More objective hiring and promotion standards and expectations that help to mitigate unconscious bias.
  • More diverse workforce and leadership makeup.
  • Higher employee retention and engagement

How to make succession planning work for your organization

Succession planning can be a tedious and complex process, especially if your organization is creating different plans for different roles simultaneously. However, the training and strategic work that goes into succession planning pays off in the long run, giving your business leaders the peace of mind to “pass the torch” if necessary. It also provides clear tracks for employees to advance their careers — a critical factor in employee engagement and retention.

The most important ingredient for any succession plan is time and investment in top talent. Browse our lists of top human capital management (HCM) software and top candidate relationship management software to start your succession planning process today.

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured HR software partners

Browse all HR software →

The post Succession Planning Examples appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
Succession Planning Examples - Explore What's Possible (2024) Considering succession planning for your business? Learn from the best examples of succession planning across multiple companies & industries in 2024. faq,HR,HR software,succession planning,succession planning examples
LMS Features You Need for a Great E-Learning Program in 2024 https://technologyadvice.com/blog/human-resources/important-learning-management-system-lms-features/ Wed, 19 Jul 2023 04:43:17 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=55133 Key takeaways: Ready to find the perfect LMS? Explore popular solutions and expert recommendations in our LMS Software Guide. 10 must-have LMS features for your training program 1. Course creation and content management It seems like course management features would be included in all LMS platform options, but the most basic functions of a learning […]

The post LMS Features You Need for a Great E-Learning Program in 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>

Key takeaways:

  • The most important features to look for in an LMS are centered around optimizing the user’s learning experience, including blended, social, mobile, and asynchronous learning modalities.
  • Other essential LMS capabilities include gamification, reporting, integrations, course creation, custom assessments, and certification management.

Jul. 18, 2023: We revised the copy for accuracy, clarity, and style. We also updated the product screenshots and added dynamic page elements to improve navigation.

Ready to find the perfect LMS? Explore popular solutions and expert recommendations in our LMS Software Guide.

10 must-have LMS features for your training program

  1. Course creation and content management
  2. Mobile learning
  3. Built-in reporting and dashboards
  4. Custom assessments
  5. Native integrations
  6. Blended learning
  7. Asynchronous learning
  8. Social learning
  9. Certification and accreditation management
  10. Gamification

1. Course creation and content management

It seems like course management features would be included in all LMS platform options, but the most basic functions of a learning management system do not include course creation. Some tools require you to bring your own content from a third-party platform, which means you’ll need to build training materials in a separate system and import them into the LMS program.

An LMS that includes native course-building features will help streamline your processes and simplify your tech stack.

Suggested platforms: Canvas, Bridge, 360Learning

Canvas displays course creation dashboard.
Canvas helps you create custom training courses from scratch. Source: Canvas

2. Mobile learning

When your LMS offers a mobile-responsive design or a native mobile app, an employee can participate in training from any location. It also gives employees the flexibility to access training materials from the devices that work best for their unique accessibility needs and learning styles.

Mobile learning is especially helpful for distributed teams and certification programs that engage in training across multiple locations. For example, a retail business can use a mobile LMS app to conduct hands-on product training in all of its stores at once.

Suggested platforms: Cornerstone LMS, Litmos LMS

SAP Litmos displays learning modules on desktop and mobile apps.
SAP Litmos offers content to learners on desktop and mobile apps. Source: SAP

3. Built-in reporting and dashboards

One of the greatest advantages of working with an LMS is administrators and team managers can access a single platform to track participation, completion, and general performance across employee training content. A customizable dashboard with detailed visualizations and charts is an essential feature for reporting and analytics, while other features — like individual progress tracking and check-in data — are also nice to have.

Suggested platforms: 360Learning, Adobe Learning Manager, Absorb LMS

360Learning dashboard displays analytics for courses, training participants, and skills assessments.
360Learning provides detailed analytics about courses, learners, and skills. Source: 360Learning

4. Custom assessments

Whether your training program is optional or required, exams and assessments are the most effective methods for testing learner engagement and knowledge retention. The best learning management systems give administrators the option to assign pre-built assessments or create their own evaluations.

Suggested platforms: Cypher Learning, 360Learning

Cypher Learning displays training assessment data.
Cypher Learning lets you see assessments for all training participants in one place. Source: Cypher

5. Native integrations

Depending on your organization’s needs and the goals of your training program, the right LMS integrations will help with tracking and managing the learning experience.

Some platforms integrate with communication and collaboration tools, like Zoom, Microsoft Teams, and Slack, to create blended and interactive learning experiences. Others integrate with department-specific platforms like Salesforce or to support on-the-job training.

Suggested platforms: Docebo, Canvas, Litmos

Docebo integrates with Salesforce to streamline sales training.
Docebo integrates with popular platforms like Salesforce to streamline department-specific training. Source: Docebo

6. Blended learning

Blended training courses are delivered both online and in person, allowing employees to choose the format that works best for their location, schedule, and learning style.

A blended program might adapt the same training materials for each setting or use one approach to supplement the other. For example, an online lesson might leverage a tutorial video to provide the same instruction as a live demonstration, or employees might participate in online role-play simulations to practice skills they learned in person.

Suggested platforms: TalentLMS, Moodle, Adobe Learning Manager, iSpring

iSpring displays a role play simulation training.
iSpring’s role play simulation trainings provide real-world interactions in a controlled, coachable environment. Source: iSpring

7. Asynchronous learning

One of the best features for improving engagement and knowledge retention is asynchronous learning — the ability for learners to complete coursework at their own pace. This means they don’t have to attend a lecture or work with an instructor at a set time.

An effective LMS organizes training videos, online readings, and discussion forums to maximize the impact of your training materials.

Suggested platforms: LearnUpon, Grovo

LearnUpon displays a list of recommended courses.
LearnUpon uses machine learning to recommend asynchronous courses based on user activity. Source: LearnUpon

8. Social learning

Learning is a fundamentally social experience, so your LMS should include features that help team members learn from one another through proven social learning methodologies. This not only enhances the learning process but also reduces the strain placed on your trainers.

By adding messaging boards and social learning features, your students can ask and answer questions in a forum setting and interact with their colleagues. The best way to show you understand a topic is by teaching it, so let your students teach each other.

Suggested platforms: TalentLMS, LearnUpon

Watch TalentLMS’ discussion forums in action:

9. Certification and accreditation management

Certification and accreditation management are important LMS functions for nearly every kind of user. It’s nice to train your employees, but you’ll have no baseline for measuring performance and improvement if you aren’t tracking skills development and certifications — or at the very least, course completion.

These LMS features can increase government compliance by consolidating your learners’ completed and pending certifications in a single exportable spreadsheet. Tracking skills and certifications also gives you the power to report on learner progress, showing the immediate return on your efforts.

Suggested platforms: Cypher Learning, Arcoro

Arcoro displays controls for managing employee training certifications.
Arcoro helps keep track of all training certifications across your organization. Source: Arcoro

10. Gamification

LMS gamification features like leaderboards, badges, and levels can turn learning into a more enticing experience. According to 2023 research from Zippia, gamification improves employee productivity by 90% and makes companies seven times more profitable than those that don’t use it.

While game elements may not make the subject matter itself more interesting, they help improve knowledge retention, completion rates, and overall engagement when implemented well.

Suggested platforms: Thought Industries, Docebo

Thought Industries displays badges and a leaderboard for gamified learning.
Thought Industries engages learners with a leaderboard, badges, and other gamification features. Source: Thought Industries

Also read: 8 Ways to Increase Employee Engagement with Your LMS

Nice-to-have LMS features to consider

In addition to the LMS features covered above, consider finding a solution that offers the following:

  • Automated workflows.
  • Notifications and reminders.
  • Surveys.
  • Multi-tenancy through multiple learning portals.
  • Automated user and assignment management with dynamic rules.
  • Smart scheduling.
  • User roles and permissions.
  • Personalized learning paths with designated learning path groups.
  • Data migration.
  • Multilingual feature with translations.
  • Single sign-on (SSO) and other cybersecurity controls.
  • Course categorization and tagging.
  • Offline learning trackers.
  • Centralized document storage.
  • Customer success and education.
  • Adherence to SCORM and industry-specific compliance requirements.

LMS FAQs

An LMS, also called a learning management system, is a type of software or application that can be used to administer online learning resources, mandatory and optional training, and certification programs.

The modern LMS comes in different shapes and sizes. Some platforms focus more heavily on employee experience, while others may specialize in industry compliance training, certification coursework, DEI training, or customer success.

A robust LMS solution not only includes content management modules but also administrative tools to track course completion, performance, and other important metrics across your organization’s e-learning program.

An LMS offers a range of benefits to trainers and trainees alike.

Administrators can use an LMS to collect employee progress and performance data, which helps determine future training opportunities. The centralized nature of an LMS also adds efficiency and consistency to training programs more broadly. Trainers can update resources in one place to ensure everyone has access to the most up-to-date information.

From the learner’s perspective, an LMS offers flexibility to choose the training style, format, and timing that works best for them. A well-implemented LMS also creates a single access point for essential company documentation as well as certification and accreditation materials. This helps teams fill critical skills gaps and empowers employees to advance in their careers.

Ready to find the perfect LMS for your business? Get started by watching our video overview of the top platforms:

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured LMS partners

Browse all LMS software →

The post LMS Features You Need for a Great E-Learning Program in 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
LMS Features You Need for a Great E-Learning Program in 2024 Are you looking for a learning management system (LMS)? See the top features needed in a modern LMS to create a successful training program. absorb lms,Adobe,canvas,cornerstone,docebo,HR,HR software,learning management system,Learning Management Systems,learnupon,lms,LMS software,TalentLMS,lms features Canvas SAP Litmos 360Learning Cypher Learning Docebo/Salesforce iSpring LearnUpon Arcoro Arcoro helps keep track of all training certifications across your organization. Source: Arcoro Thought Industries
7 Best Management Training Programs for 2024 https://technologyadvice.com/blog/human-resources/management-training-programs/ Fri, 01 Mar 2024 02:22:46 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=119382 Key takeaways Top 7 management training programs All of the management training programs in this list have clear incentives, such as certifications, degrees, or badges that support career growth opportunities. 1. Coaching Skills for Managers Coaching Skills for Managers is an online specialization program from Coursera and UC Davis that focuses on helping managers improve […]

The post 7 Best Management Training Programs for 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>

Key takeaways

  • Coursera, Udacity, Udemy, TechRepublic, and Master of Project Academy offer the best online training programs to develop managers’ leadership skills.
  • If none of the prebuilt management training programs fit your business’s requirements, consider investing in a learning management system that allows you to build custom training courses.
TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured Partners

Top 7 management training programs

All of the management training programs in this list have clear incentives, such as certifications, degrees, or badges that support career growth opportunities.

1. Coaching Skills for Managers

Coaching Skills for Managers is an online specialization program from Coursera and UC Davis that focuses on helping managers improve their skills in employee coaching and related skills like communication and active listening. The course teaches coaching best practices and concrete conversational skills for managers, and it includes an entire section on setting clear expectations and managing performance in a culture of accountability.

After users complete all four courses, they will earn a career certificate from UC Davis that can be shared on LinkedIn, resumes, and other professional documents. Alternatively, managers have the option to complete just one course if they’re only interested in that topic.

Coaching Skills for Managers
Program structure Four courses, 20 lessons
Provider University of California, Davis via Coursera
Best for New and experienced managers who want to learn effective performance management techniques
Main topics Coaching, performance management, accountability, setting expectations, active listening, and communication
Cost Included in Coursera Plus (starting at $59/month); free audit without certification
Program duration Self-paced (two months estimated at 10 hours per week)
Prerequisites None

2. Organizational Leadership in Diversity, Equity & Inclusion

Organizational Leadership in Diversity, Equity & Inclusion is a Coursera specialization program from Rice University that focuses on specifics like DEI strategic planning and DEI program assessment. The course collection also trains managers and other business leaders on how to foster a more inclusive workplace environment and how to plan and execute DEI interventions. Managers who complete this set of courses will earn a career certificate from Rice University.

Organizational Leadership in Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
Program structure Four courses, 20 lessons
Provider Rice University via Coursera
Best for DEI leaders, HR leaders, and others who play a role in shaping company culture
Main topics DEI, organizational DEI, DEI interventions, cultural climate, and creating an inclusive workplace
Cost Included in Coursera Plus (starting at $59/month); free audit without certification
Program duration Self-paced (one month estimated at six hours per week)
Prerequisites Though not required, learners should have an existing understanding of DEI and DEI programming

3. AI for Business Leaders

AI for Business Leaders is a set of two courses from Udacity that gives concrete examples and training to business leaders who want to embed machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) into their business workflows, tools, and practices.

The program includes a blend of online learning and real-world project opportunities to train users in basic AI/ML knowledge, AI ethics and bias detection, and other skills that are necessary for developing internal AI initiatives and policies. This is considered a nano-degree program and culminates in a completion certificate.

AI for Business Leaders
Program structure Two courses, 11 lessons
Provider Udacity
Best for Managers and leaders looking to incorporate AI into business workflows in a sustainable, strategic, and ethical way
Main topics Artificial intelligence, machine learning, AI architecture, big data and data best practices, AI ethics, and developing an AI strategy for your business
Cost Included in Udacity subscription (starting at $249/month)
Program duration Self-paced (two months estimated)
Prerequisites No prior experience required

4. New Manager: The Basics and More of Being a Great Leader

New Manager: The Basics and More of Being a Great Leader is a management training course from Udemy delivered via blended materials that include on-demand videos, articles, and downloadable learning resources.

The program focuses on how employees can shift from specialist to manager effectively, how to give and receive feedback effectively, how to manage conflict and group dynamics, how to set up employees for success in their performance, and more. Upon course completion, students receive a certificate of completion.

New Manager: The Basics and More of Being a Great Leader
Program structure One course, 20 lessons
Provider Udemy
Best for New managers
Main topics New manager training, management vs. leadership, giving and receiving feedback, communication, conflict management, delegation, coaching, decision making, and time management
Cost $24.99 (one time, regularly $129.99); included in Udemy subscription (starting at $20/month)
Program duration Seven hours and 18 minutes
Prerequisites No prior experience required

5. Project Management Professional Certification Training

Master of Project Academy’s PMP Certification Online Training Bundle prepares project managers with the material and knowledge they need to pass the Project Management Professional (PMP) certification exam.

The program includes self-paced certification training, lectures, PMP practice questions, cheat sheets, and nine sample exams to help students prepare for the test. There are also 20 real-world situational project cases, which help to give project managers the scenario-based skills they need to handle different types of projects and project issues. 

Project Management Professional Certification Training
Program structure Three courses, 300+ lectures
Provider Master of Project Academy
Best for Project managers, product managers, team leads
Main topics Project management, people management, process management, agile and hybrid project management, and strategic goal management
Cost Starting at $117/month; annual subscription and lifetime access options available
Program duration 60+ hours
Prerequisites Basic project management knowledge and experience recommended

6. Interpersonal Skills for Elite Leaders & Project Managers

Interpersonal Skills for Elite Leaders & Project Managers is a management training program from TechRepublic Academy that gives users lifetime access to courses on verbal and nonverbal communication best practices and increasing profesisonal influence. Students receive a certificate after completing these courses.

Interpersonal Skills for Elite Leaders & Project Managers
Program structure One course, 21 lectures
Provider TechRepublic Academy
Best for New managers and project managers working with new team dynamics.
Main topics Interpersonal skills and relationship building, nonverbal body language and cues, verbal cues, and telephonic conversations
Cost $19.99 (one time), regularly $80
Program duration One hour
Prerequisites No prior experience required

7. Effective Delegation for New Managers

Effective Delegation for New Managers is a Udemy management training course that specializes in teaching new leaders how to better manage their own schedules through effective task delegation. The goal of a course like this is to help new managers move from successful individual contributors into the role of a manager who knows what work to complete and what work to pass off to members of their team.

Some of the specific skills that this program focuses on include manager-to-employee communication, how to avoid common delegation errors, and how to develop your direct reports for succession planning. This course includes a certificate of completion.

Effective Delegation for New Managers
Program structure One course, five lessons
Provider Udemy
Best for New managers, especially those who are managing former peers on the same team
Main topics Task delegation, personal and professional development, developing subordinates’ skills, communication, setting clear goals, and giving feedback
Cost $14.99 (one time, regularly $64.99); included in Udemy subscription (starting at $20/month)
Program duration 36 minutes
Prerequisites No prior experience required

Tips and best practices for implementing management training programs

Managers are often put into positions where they need to solve both business and interpersonal problems within their project teams, not to mention client-facing problems, so it’s important to give them training that helps them develop necessary business and cultural competencies in all of these areas.

Scenario-based training, live training, and other hands-on training formats are the best ways to build these creative problem-solving skills, as managers are given an opportunity to test and hone their existing skills for conflicts they may not have faced in prior roles.

New managers are in a completely different place in their career than experienced managers, and a good management training program recognizes the need for tiered training paths. Consider providing training programs or different courses that address their unique challenges and levels of expertise.

Additionally, make it clear how these programs fit into different phases of a manager’s career and their opportunities for further growth; you can do this by designating specific courses as required or encouraged milestones in your competency frameworks, career roadmaps, and any other documentation you use to illustrate how employees can grow in their careers.

Leaders in different kinds of businesses will have unique roles and responsibilities and should receive training that reflects those responsibilities. For example, PMP and project management training may be helpful for managers in consulting and service-driven industries, while more generic training programs are a better fit for managers in other industries.

Ultimately, don’t pick a one-size-fits-all management training program if a specialized program is a better fit. Also, pay attention to greater industry and workplace trends, such as AI, which may impact the topics you choose to focus on in management and leadership training going forward.

Managers are more likely to complete management training if it factors into their growth potential with the organization. To show how important this training is to the organization as a whole, build training milestones into promotion paths and find other ways to offer relevant training that builds on-the-job skills that interest your managers.

Managers may also prefer to complete courses that come with certification and degree opportunities, badges, or gamified rewards.

Invest in LMS software to build your own training program

If you desire a more customized training program or have an in-house learning and development team that wants to craft a unique training plan, many learning management system (LMS) solutions give users the ability to build their own training programs and courses.

Some of the benefits of building your own training program with LMS software include the option for more flexible training formats, easier in-house assessments of training performance, and the ability to monitor training progress at an individual and organizational level.

If you’re not sure where to start in your search for LMS software, 360Learning, TalentLMS, and Docebo are all LMS solutions that enable users to create their own courses and training paths.

Explore more LMS options →

TalentLMS displays a dialogue box with configuration options for a conflict management training course.
TalentLMS is an example of an LMS that makes it possible to create tailored management training courses. Source: TalentLMS

Management training FAQs

Management training programs are online, in-person, and/or hybrid training programs that focus on building skills that are necessary for managers to thrive when interacting with their direct reports, executive leaders, company stakeholders, and clients and customers. Because managers are shifting from individual contributors to roles with greater organizational leadership requirements, many trainings go beyond the technical skills of that department and focus on soft skills and emotional intelligence.

A management training program gives managers clear objectives and scenario-based ideas about how to effectively interact with, assess, advocate for, and build up other members of their team in a way that contributes to the business’s growth and positive culture. Management training programs also give managers a clearer picture of how to do their jobs, particularly in difficult situations like conflict mediation, task delegation, or sales cycles with clients.

The post 7 Best Management Training Programs for 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
TalentLMS displays a dialogue box with configuration options for a conflict management training course.
Upskilling Your Workforce in 2024 https://technologyadvice.com/blog/human-resources/what-is-upskilling/ Wed, 06 Sep 2023 00:07:21 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=112336 Learn about the importance of upskilling and retraining your workforce in 2023, and explore strategies to help you create a modern and engaged workforce.

The post Upskilling Your Workforce in 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>

Key takeaways

  • Upskilling programs are less focused on teaching employees entirely new skill sets and more on enhancing their existing skills as they grow in their careers.
  • Transparency and engagement are the two biggest keys to upskilling program success; make sure employees feel seen and heard when designing your upskilling program.
  • A variety of learning management software solutions, online course programs, and other resources can help you streamline the upskilling process and even create your own upskilling coursework.

What is upskilling in the workplace?

Upskilling in the workplace is a focused effort, usually from HR or organizational leadership, to give employees the resources they need to enhance and build on their existing skills. Upskilling programs typically offer on-the-job training and career path resources that help employees clearly visualize career growth opportunities and take the necessary steps toward achieving new career milestones that interest them. 

Examples of upskilling include:

  • A financial analyst at a consulting firm receives 1:1 mentorship and completes online training courses to become a specialized finance solutions architect.
  • An on-page SEO analyst is trained by their team lead to take on technical SEO responsibilities.
  • A team manager receives focused leadership training in order to become a successful senior manager.
  • A digital marketing specialist completes a Google Analytics certification and a social media marketing certification course to improve their ability to manage and measure audience engagement.

What’s the difference?

Unlike reskilling, upskilling is focused on strengthening a person’s current job skills and building related skills that will help the employee further specialize in their career. Reskilling focuses on teaching employees entirely new skills so they can shift to a different kind of role in the company.

Reskilling and upskilling are slightly different and serve different organizational purposes, but both are important strategies for optimizing your organization’s internal talent pool.

How to successfully implement an upskilling program

Setting up an upskilling program for your organization requires thoughtful design, buy-in from leaders and managers, and a continued willingness to adjust to employee needs and interests. For the best chances of success, follow these steps when starting your upskilling program:

1. Seek out employee input on knowledge gaps and areas of interest

Your organization’s leadership likely has an idea of where knowledge and skills gaps exist in the organization, so it’s a good idea to get their input and support when performing a skills gap analysis.

However, you should also place a premium on your employees’ opinions when it comes to designing an upskilling program. Individual employees have first-hand knowledge of their own strengths and weaknesses, and if they’re invested in their role and committed to career growth, they probably already have ideas for training resources that will help them fill their knowledge gaps. Leverage survey tools to collect employee feedback on knowledge gaps and areas of interest.

Similarly, establishing a strong line of communication between employees and their managers and mentors helps boost employees’ confidence when it comes to their career goals. It also gives managers and mentors more visibility into relevant knowledge and skills gaps that need to be addressed.

2. Develop clear training and career paths

Transparency is key when it comes to encouraging employees to engage with upskilling programs. That’s why it’s important to clearly communicate which training courses are required and which ones are encouraged for career growth in various departments and roles. 

Career paths and roadmaps are great tools for illustrating what competencies, certifications, and other milestones must be achieved to grow into either a specialist or a leadership role within a department. These illustrations can be part of a competency framework, sit inside a learning management solution, or act as standalone resources.

Regardless of how you set up your training and career paths, be sure to share this information with employees and keep these resources updated as your internal role requirements change or evolve.

3. Invest in relevant training programs and software

Organizations that want to automate or otherwise streamline upskilling program implementation should invest in third-party learning resources. Learning management software is typically the most helpful upskilling program resource, as it helps you track employee participation, automate course assignments, and even build your own training programs.

Udacity, TalentLMS, and BetterUp are all great examples of software that can take the guesswork out of upskilling program management, helping leaders create and manage training programs that are both interesting and relevant.

Udacity offers nanodegree programs for relevant workplace skills like introductory programming. Source: Udacity.

For the best possible results, you should mix in a variety of training and learning resources that fit different learning styles and interests. Consider building a digital and a physical library with materials on various topics, subscribing to online certification courses and programs, providing vouchers for local trade and software schools, extending employee coaching opportunities, and taking other steps that show you’re willing to get creative and mold your program to your employee’s interests and your company’s growth goals.

More on a similar topic: 8 Ways to Increase Employee Engagement With Your LMS

4. Assess employee engagement on a regular basis

Especially if you’re using learning management software or another tool with administrative reporting and dashboarding capabilities, your HR or learning and development team will want to measure the success of upskilling programs. The data these tools provide is useful on its own, but it’s much more helpful if your HR team determines employee engagement goals and other KPIs in advance.

TalentLMS displays a dashboard with overviews of LMS engagement metrics like logins, users with activity, course completion rates, and active vs. inactive courses.
This admin dashboard from TalentLMS allows business leaders to easily track upskilling program engagement across the organization and at an individual level. Source: TalentLMS

If you’re not sure what to measure when assessing employee engagement with upskilling programs, consider looking at the following data points and setting goals and KPIs around them:

  • Percentage of employees who have completed one course during this week, month, or quarter.
  • Percentage of employees who have completed more than one course or a certification program during this week, month, or quarter.
  • Percentage of employees who have logged into the software without completing any courses.
  • Percentage of employees who have never logged into the software.
  • Percentage of employees who have completed one-and-done programs versus multiple training programs.
  • Percentage of employees who have earned a promotion and completed relevant coursework toward that promotion.

5. Reward employee participation with career growth opportunities

Employees should see themselves and their peers succeed as a result of completing upskilling program initiatives. If your leaders commit to an upskilling program, it’s important that this program’s results and employee participation factor into promotions, raises, and other opportunities to grow within the company. Making upskilling part of your competency frameworks and role-banding efforts will motivate employees to build on their skills and make the most of the learning resources you provide.

But rewards don’t have to always be promotions and raises; game-based learning can make upskilling programs both fun and rewarding, giving users the opportunity to earn relevant badges or perhaps points or tokens that help them reach a larger personal or professional goal.

Bottom line: Support employee development with an upskilling program

Businesses are sometimes hesitant to get started with upskilling programs because of the initial cost and setup effort required. However, what business leaders often don’t realize is that many free and near-free resources are available to help manage upskilling programs. 

Additionally, upskilling programs quickly prove their worth, giving employees the skills and confidence they need to do better work and grow into more experienced roles through quiet hiring. When relevant and interesting upskilling resources are made available to employees, they’re more likely to avoid burnout and stay with the company as it invests in their personal and professional growth.

Upskilling programs support both employee retention and internal hiring efforts, making these programs valuable to everyone from the CEO to the newest hire.

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured LMS partners

Browse all LMS software →

The post Upskilling Your Workforce in 2024 appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
TalentLMS displays a dashboard with overviews of LMS engagement metrics like logins, users with activity, course completion rates, and active vs. inactive courses.
Project Manager Job Description & Responsibilities https://technologyadvice.com/blog/project-management/project-manager-job-description/ Tue, 26 Mar 2024 14:56:52 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=121206 Key takeaways 8 core responsibilities of a project manager Project managers must balance a number of different responsibilities to complete a project successfully. These core responsibilities illustrate some of their most important skills, priorities, and areas of focus: 1. Define project parameters and big-picture goals In the earliest stages of project planning, project managers must […]

The post Project Manager Job Description & Responsibilities appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>

Key takeaways

  • Project managers have multiple responsibilities throughout a project’s lifecycle, including in the pre-planning and post-launch phases.
  • A successful project manager is a good communicator and leader who excels in time management, strategic planning, and risk management.
  • The right project management software can help project managers juggle all of their obligations to their team and the client.

8 core responsibilities of a project manager

Project managers must balance a number of different responsibilities to complete a project successfully. These core responsibilities illustrate some of their most important skills, priorities, and areas of focus:

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured Partners

1. Define project parameters and big-picture goals

In the earliest stages of project planning, project managers must meet with internal and/or external project stakeholders to understand their big picture goals and expectations.

Because this pre-planning or “discovery phase” may be too early for stakeholders to know what they need and what they can afford, it is the project manager’s job to help them understand what’s possible and prioritize the most important project deliverables if budget runs low. If necessary, the project manager may also need to bring in subject matter experts to explain how the project team will handle specific requests or tasks.

2. Assemble and lead a project team

Whether or not they have direct people management responsibilities, project managers are responsible for assembling and leading a team of professionals who have the necessary skills and availability. These may be software developers, data analysts, digital marketers and designers, finance specialists, or business associates, depending on the type of project work. 

Project managers may also indirectly manage and coordinate more experienced specialists, including client success managers, technical or finance leads, product managers, QA testers, and risk managers.

3. Identify and schedule project tasks and resources

Once a basic project outline and team members are in place, project managers need to determine what will be required to complete the project. This involves setting more specific project milestones that fold into the project’s bigger goals.

More specifically, project managers need to allocate resources and create detailed timelines for each project task and subtask; this step is particularly crucial to staying on budget and deadline.

4. (Re)set deadlines

In theory, setting deadlines for a project should be fairly easy, but it’s often necessary for project managers to pivot around unexpected obstacles. To keep an eye out for potential scope creep or bottlenecks that will impact project timelines, project managers must regularly check in with both project team members and clients to gauge task progress, overall satisfaction, and any new project variables or goals that may arise.

5. Maintain internal team communications and schedules

Project managers typically oversee multiple project team members who are individually responsible for different tasks, deliverables, and deadlines. It is important for the project manager to set reasonable deadlines across all of these roles and proactively communicate wins, challenges, and other helpful project updates.

In addition to one-on-one messaging, project managers must facilitate teamwide communication and collaboration to ensure everyone understands how they contribute to bigger project goals. Effective internal communications help strengthen team morale and interpersonal relationships, leading to smoother projects overall.

6. Maintain stakeholder communications

One of the most important responsibilities of a project manager is stakeholder relationship management. Whether the project is internal-only or a collaboration with external clients, all projects have stakeholders with unique expectations, goals, and priorities.

Project managers need to stay in constant communication with these individuals about the project’s progress. Regular status updates establish strong stakeholder relationships with mutual trust and bidirectional communication — stakeholders often have important updates that will help move the project forward.

Get started: How to Create a Project Status Report [Template & Examples]

7. Anticipate and mitigate project risks

Whether it’s scope creep, resource constraints, other limitations, project managers must proactively prepare for as many risks as possible and take action to address problems as soon as they surface. Known risks should be acknowledged at the start of a project, and as new risks come to light, the project manager needs to communicate both the problem and viable solutions to all stakeholders in a timely fashion.

8. Monitor and report on project progress and performance

Progress tracking at macro and micro levels is an important part of a project manager’s job. The project plan should identify which metrics the project manager will use to track progress and how often stakeholders will receive status updates. Depending on the project’s requirements, project managers may need to report progress on a daily, weekly, monthly, or quarterly basis.

Project manager requirements and qualifications

While there are no legal requirements to become a professional project manager, several organizations share similar requirements and prerequisites:

  • Previous experience working on a project team.
  • Previous people or team management experience.
  • Previous customer service or client-facing work experience.
  • Previous experience in a particular industry or niche.
  • A bachelor’s or master’s degree in business administration or industry-specific field.
  • Experience with project management software tools and relevant methodologies.
  • The Project Management Professional (PMP) certification from the Project Management Institute or other project management certifications.

Key skills for a project manager

Industries like software development, healthcare, and construction often require specialized project management skills and expertise, but all project managers must have the same fundamental skills regardless of their industry:

  • Strong verbal and written communication, with an emphasis on stakeholder management.
  • Organization.
  • Individual and team-focused time management.
  • Strategic problem-solving and conflict-resolution.
  • Risk management and data analysis.
  • Project scheduling and forecasting.
  • Leadership and delegation.
  • Adaptability and listening.
  • Budgeting and resource management.

Important tools and software for a project manager

Some of the most important tools project managers need to be effective include project management and project portfolio management (PPM) software, time tracking software, version control and developer tools, and collaboration and communication tools.

Project and portfolio management software

Project management and PPM software can be used to organize, automate, and analyze individual components of a project or multiple projects. Many project management solutions include time tracking, communication, billing and invoicing, and other helpful features for all aspects of the project lifecycle.

Examples:

  • monday work management.
  • Trello.
  • Asana.
  • ClickUp.
  • Wrike.
A sample monday work management dashboard displays task details for multiple clients and deliverables.
A project management tool like monday work management helps project managers quickly track overall progress, task statuses, and individual team members’ hours. Source: monday.com

Time tracking software

Time tracking software helps project team members track time spent on projects or project tasks, which can be helpful for more accurate billing and scope management. Time tracking is often built into project management software.

Examples:

  • ClickUp.
  • Celoxis.
  • Teamwork.
  • Wrike.
  • Toggl Track.

Version control and app development software

For more technical projects and initiatives, it may be necessary to invest in version control or app development software. This can help your team better visualize progress, collaboratively work on tasks, and easily handle rollbacks when needed.

Examples:

  • Jira.
  • Airtable.
  • ProofHub.
  • Azure DevOps Server.
  • Git.
An example of how users can manage different versions of a product in development within Jira.
Jira’s specialized software development features make it easy to plan for future releases. Source: Atlassian

Collaboration and communication software

Collaboration and communication software enable project teams to align with each other on projects and individual tasks. These tools may support messaging, comment threads, and/or video calling. Many of these features are also baked into project management software, as you’ll see in the examples listed below.

Examples:

  • Slack.
  • Microsoft Teams.
  • Google Docs.
  • Hive.
  • Trello.

FAQs

A project manager is a professional who manages the entire lifecycle of a project, whether it’s an internal or external initiative.

Project managers handle planning, tactical, and strategic work that goes into their assigned projects. They may manage multiple people, resources, deadlines, and deliverables and need strong time management and strategic problem-solving skills.

Project managers manage individual projects and focus on each project’s unique problems and goals. Program managers oversee strategic outcomes, bigger-picture planning, and higher-level risk mitigation for multiple projects simultaneously.

Project managers focus on tasks, milestones, and deliverables for their projects, which may or may not involve product development. Product managers focus on product vision and overall product development strategy, ensuring the final product meets user expectations.

The post Project Manager Job Description & Responsibilities appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>
monday.com time tracking screenshot Jira Software screenshot Jira's specialized software development features make it easy to plan for future releases. Source: Atlassian
Top Employee Performance Review Templates for HR Managers https://technologyadvice.com/blog/human-resources/employee-performance-review-templates/ Thu, 24 Aug 2023 19:10:09 +0000 https://technologyadvice.com/?p=59368 Key takeaways Performance management software can simplify the review process. Browse top solutions in our Performance Management Software Guide to get started. What is a performance review? A performance review is a formal feedback process in which a manager monitors performance over a designated review cycle, assesses performance against preset goals and standards, and then […]

The post Top Employee Performance Review Templates for HR Managers appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>

Key takeaways

  • A number of performance management software solutions and brands offer complimentary, customizable performance review templates.
  • An effective performance review process leaves room for personal reflections; build space into review templates for employee self-evaluations.
  • Having a structured performance review template and process in place will ensure everyone stays on the same page about current production goals and future growth plans.

Aug. 24, 2023: We refocused the content to offer more valuable information about performance review templates and how to use them. We also provided information about what to include in a performance review template if you decide to create your own. Finally, we added linked resources for performance review templates and tools that support a smooth employee performance evaluation process.

Performance management software can simplify the review process. Browse top solutions in our Performance Management Software Guide to get started.

What is a performance review?

A performance review is a formal feedback process in which a manager monitors performance over a designated review cycle, assesses performance against preset goals and standards, and then discusses performance and future goals with a direct report. The reviews may occur monthly, quarterly, bi-annually, or annually, but, regardless of their frequency, they should include formal documentation and individualized employee feedback.

What is an employee review template? 

An employee review template is a structured document or framework that managers and HR professionals can use to structure employee performance reviews. These templates can either be used as is or as a baseline for creating your own employee performance review template.

What are the benefits of a performance review?

Performance reviews help employees and their managers get on the same page about their performance, what’s going well, and where the employee is struggling. Managers have formal opportunities to coach and share constructive feedback with their employees, employees have a platform to voice concerns and questions, and both parties have space to discuss future growth, training, and professional development opportunities.

More on this topic: Why Is Performance Management So Important?

Performance review best practices

If your organization is just getting started with performance reviews, here are a few quick tips and best practices to consider:

  • Set goals before you begin, designing key performance indicators (KPIs) around company values, business goals, company goals, department goals, and individual goals based on job role.
  • Have regular informal check-ins (with documentation) leading up to formal reviews in order to build a culture of consistent performance appraisal and transparent feedback with direct reports.
  • Make reviews reciprocal, giving employees a chance to review themselves (or you) and share their thoughts on their progress, goals, and challenges.
  • Focus on the metrics that matter, and consider adopting a results-only work environment that rewards employee productivity appropriately.
  • Invest in performance management software to guide your processes.
  • Use performance review templates to consistently structure your reviews.

What to include in a performance review template

Performance review templates serve an important purpose: adding structure and standardized processes to reviews for all employees, ensuring everyone gets a fair chance to discuss their performance and opportunities for growth within the organization.

For teams that want to create performance review templates from scratch, regardless of industry or department, it’s important to include basic employee information, a clear scoring system, a self-evaluation, core competencies, quantitative KPIs or OKRs, qualitative feedback, future goals, and a signature section.

Employee information

Your performance review form should include space for the employee’s name, department, role, review period, and any other information that’s relevant for archival purposes.

Clear scoring system

Each evaluation category in your review template should require reviewers to give a quantifiable performance rating — one to five, for example. This makes it easier to standardize and compare performance across individuals, teams, and departments who are doing different kinds of work.

Self-evaluation

Employees should be given space to assess their own job performance during the past review cycle, highlighting any big wins, questions, concerns, and goals they have for the future. This is one of the most important parts of your performance review because it gives employees a chance to steer their own careers and communicate candidly with their managers.

Core competencies 

Core competencies will typically be role- or department-specific, covering all of the bases for what an employee must be able to do in order to succeed in their role. It’s important to customize this section; managers, individual producers, and interns will all have different core competencies that make sense for their positions, for example.

Quantitative KPIs or OKRs

Include KPIs and/or objectives and key results (OKRs) to judge how this individual, their team, and their department performed against specific goals during the review cycle. This is a necessary review component for judging employee productivity against the organization’s most important goals.

Qualitative feedback

Employees should be evaluated on qualities that are harder to quantify, such as communication skills, leadership skills, organizational skills, and how they measure up against specific company values. Though this part of the review template can be expressed through numeric scores, it’s important to leave room for comments and written feedback to contextualize the ratings.

Future goals

This area of the template should cover goals the manager has set for the employee as well as any goals the employee wants to accomplish before the next review cycle; these goals can focus on training and development and/or areas for improvement and development.

Signature and date

At the bottom of the template, designate space for a signature and date to make it easier to confirm the process has been followed and the review completed. Ideally, both the reviewer and the reviewee should sign off on the document.

Space for notes and unstructured feedback

Leave additional space for reviewers to leave comments for the reviewee if desired.

Space for updated financial and role information

Consider having a specific template area to denote any changes in role or compensation, including promotions, raises, and bonuses for that review cycle.

Continue reading about the importance of performance-based bonuses: How Performance Bonuses Help Avoid Bias and Increase Productivity.

Performance review templates and tools

If you’d prefer to get started with a performance review template from a trusted source, a number of HR leaders, software vendors, and job boards have designed review templates and resources that anyone can access.

Performance review template examples

Performance review templates can be found on their Evaluation forms page. Relevant templates include:

  • Employee Evaluation Form Template.
  • 360 Degree Feedback Form Template.
  • 90-Day Evaluation Form Template.

These templates take a survey-based approach. Relevant templates include:

  • Short Employee Performance Review Survey and Sample Question.
  • 360 Degree Review Survey Template.
  • Employee Self Assessment Survey Template.

SHRM is one of the largest professional HR organizations in the world. They have a number of HR forms and checklists that are relevant for performance reviews, including:

  • Performance Appraisal: Employee Review Form.
  • Performance Appraisal: Qualitative Evaluation Form.
  • Intern Evaluation Form.

The job site has put together 10 simple performance review templates. The templates include:

  • GOOD performance review.
  • Numerical scale performance review.
  • Mid-year performance review.

Smartsheet is primarily project management software, but it also includes a large library of templates. Its performance management templates include:

  • Employee Review Checklist Template.
  • Employee Objectives & Performance Review Template.

ClickUp is another project management solution that includes performance management templates in its template library. Relevant templates include:

  • Employee Action Plan.
  • Evaluation Report.
  • Quarterly Performance Review.

Performance management software examples

BambooHR’s performance management product includes manager and self-assessments, customizable performance review cycles, scheduled assessments, automated reminders, employee goal-setting, and status reports.

Learn more about BambooHR’s performance review tools:

PerformYard enables automated reviews, scheduled reminders, approval notifications, review form imports, and several review format options.

Learn more about PerformYard’s performance review tools:

Leapsome offers a review builder, best practice templates and frameworks, automated review cycles, skill profiles, people analytics, and cycle dashboards.

Learn more about Leapsome’s performance review tools:

Paylocity’s performance management module includes performance goal setting, text and video journals, customizable feedback forms, peer recognition, self-appraisal, and nine-box talent assessment templates.

Learn more about Paylocity’s performance review tools:

Want to browse other performance management tools? Explore our Performance Management Software Guide to find expert recommendations and a full catalog of top solutions.

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured Partners

Browse all performance management software →

The post Top Employee Performance Review Templates for HR Managers appeared first on TechnologyAdvice.

]]>