Key takeaways

  • A project management methodology is a set of principles and processes for effectively managing projects.
  • Some widely used project management methodologies include waterfall, Agile, Kanban, Scrum, and Lean.
  • When choosing a methodology, consider industry standards as well as the project’s size, goals, and risks.

What is a project management methodology?

A project management methodology is a set of guiding principles and processes for effectively planning, executing, and overseeing projects. PM methodologies can vary widely, depending on the nature of the project and the industry. They can range from traditional, linear approaches to more flexible and iterative frameworks.

A project’s methodology can be the deciding factor in its success. It provides the structure for managing various aspects of a project, such as time, cost, quality, and resources. Project managers maintain consistency and control throughout the project lifecycle by adhering to a specific methodology.

This structured approach facilitates clear communication, sets expectations, and provides a roadmap for achieving project goals. More importantly, it allows you to identify and mitigate risks to make sure the project stays on track and within its defined scope.

Types of project management methodologies

Various project management methods offer distinct frameworks and approaches to achieving project goals. Each methodology paves the way for project success and is tailored to different project needs, team dynamics, and industry demands.

Waterfall

The waterfall methodology is a sequential, linear approach to project management, that is divided into five highly structured phases. Each phase must be completed before the next begins, with no overlap or iteration. Originating in manufacturing and construction, this methodology best suits projects with clear, fixed requirements and time constraints. 

Waterfall emphasizes thorough planning and documentation and makes sure that every project detail is well-defined and understood by all team members from its commencement. The waterfall method is particularly effective for projects where changes are unlikely or costly, as it does not easily accommodate mid-project adjustments. This methodology’s clarity and predictability make it a reliable choice for projects with well-established parameters.

A flowchart outlining the sequential stages of waterfall project management: requirements, design, implementation, testing, and maintenance.
The sequential stages of waterfall project management from requirements to maintenance. Source: TechnologyAdvice

Pros

  • Sequential phases provide a clear project structure.
  • The outcome of the project is more predictable because this approach minimizes uncertainty and deviations as each phase builds directly upon the previous one.
  • Easy to measure progress due to its sequential phases with specific deliverables and milestones.

Cons

  • Its rigid approach eliminates flexibility to make changes.
  • The end product of a long project may become outdated by the time it’s completed.
  • Limited stakeholder involvement creates a risk of communication gaps and misaligned expectations.

When to use waterfall

Sectors like construction, manufacturing, and specific areas of software development are ideal candidates for waterfall methodology because they have clear scopes with minimal changes. For instance, in construction, each phase, like foundation laying, framing, and finishing, must be completed in sequence. Similarly, the production process in manufacturing follows a linear path from design to assembly. Even in software development, projects with fixed requirements and a clear end goal benefit from waterfall’s structured approach.

Tools like Microsoft Project and Asana are well-suited for this methodology. These platforms offer features like Gantt charts and detailed project planning capabilities, which align perfectly with waterfall’s sequential and phase-based nature. They allow for clear documentation of each stage, resource allocation, and timeline tracking so that each phase can progress as planned.

Visit Microsoft Project Visit Asana

Agile

Agile project management is an iterative approach focusing on continuous releases and customer feedback. It’s characterized by its flexibility, adaptability, and emphasis on collaboration and customer satisfaction. Agile frameworks like Scrum and Kanban are favored in software development because they allow teams to respond quickly to changes and deliver value incrementally.

Pros

  • It can easily adapt to changes and evolving project requirements because it is inherently iterative and flexible.
  • Regular feedback loops ensure the product meets customer needs.
  • Incremental delivery allows for early detection and correction of issues.

Cons

  • Long-term resource allocation and market prediction can be challenging due to its flexibility.
  • Requires constant collaboration and communication, which can require significant time and attention from team members.
  • The project’s scope can expand uncontrollably without careful management.

When to use Agile

Agile methodology is also highly beneficial for various sectors beyond software development. Marketing agencies use it to adapt to evolving market trends and client demands swiftly. Educational institutions may implement Agile to develop and update curriculum responsively. Additionally, financial services like banks and investment firms can rapidly employ Agile to respond to market changes and regulatory requirements.

Jira is a particularly effective tool among the various Agile project management software solutions. Jira, created by Atlassian, supports Agile frameworks through customizable boards for tracking progress. Jira also offers robust reporting features like burndown charts, which are essential for monitoring the progress of Agile projects. Its ability to integrate with various other tools and platforms further enhances its utility.

Visit Jira

Discover the key differences between Agile and waterfall methodologies, and decide which is best for your project needs.

Kanban

Kanban, originating from a Japanese word meaning “signboard,” was developed in the 1940s by a Toyota engineer named Taiichi Ohno. It’s an Agile framework that visualizes and improves workflows and enhances team focus by limiting work in progress (WIP).

Kanban categorizes tasks on a visual board according to their production phase, such as To-Do, In Progress, and Complete. This visibility aids in identifying bottlenecks or delays, keeps a balanced distribution of tasks, and enables easy adjustments to priorities. It also fosters team collaboration, as everyone can see the status of each task.

Kanban adapts to existing roles and team structures, so it is widely applicable across various industries, including IT, service delivery, and operations.

Pros

  • Kanban boards provide a clear visual representation of WIP.
  • Limiting WIP helps prevent team overload and burnout.
  • Regular, incremental progress and delivery can lead to faster completion of tasks and projects.

Cons

  • Team members must be highly disciplined and self-sufficient.
  • Kanban might not be sufficient for projects requiring detailed planning and stages as its primary focus is on visualizing current workloads rather than complex project stages.
  • Can lead to a lack of long-term planning because its focus on current WIP and task turnover might overshadow the attention to long-term goals and strategic planning.

When to use Kanban

In software development, Kanban improves visibility and prioritization of workflow, so it’s easier to adapt to changes. Kanban’s just-in-time production and efficient inventory management approach make the best use of resources in manufacturing. Healthcare organizations utilize Kanban to provide timely treatment and monitor resource availability. Retail businesses employ Kanban for stock management and customer service improvements to align product availability with demand.

Trello is an excellent project management software solution for implementing the Kanban framework. Renowned for its intuitive and user-friendly Kanban boards, Trello enables teams to create, manage, and visualize tasks in a highly interactive environment. Each board in Trello represents a project, with cards for individual tasks that can be moved across columns representing different workflow stages. This setup aligns perfectly with Kanban’s core principles of visualizing workflow, limiting work in progress, and managing tasks efficiently.

Visit Trello

Scrum

Scrum is a popular Agile framework used for developing complex products and systems. It’s based on brief, focused meetings where team members discuss project progress, next steps, and potential challenges. Scrum emphasizes expedited product delivery with high quality through “Sprints” — short, regular work cycles, typically not exceeding four weeks. It operates on the “do, check, adapt” principle, promoting continuous improvement and effective risk management through iterative and incremental approaches.

Pros

  • Daily stand-up meetings and regular retrospectives create a collaborative environment.
  • Continuous feedback and iterative testing lead to higher-quality products.
  • Regular reviews and updates keep stakeholders engaged and informed.

Cons

  • The need for frequent meetings and updates can be resource-heavy and time-consuming.
  • Team members must have a high level of expertise and self-sufficiency.
  • The iterative nature makes predicting project outcomes and timelines challenging.

When to use Scrum

Scrum methodology is particularly beneficial for organizations involved in complex product development, such as software companies, technology startups, and research and development departments in various industries. Additionally, Scrum is advantageous for marketing agencies and consulting firms, where projects often require rapid adaptation and iterative development. 

monday.com helps you facilitate collaboration, track progress, and manage Sprints. It allows teams to create customizable workflows that mirror Scrum processes, including Sprint planning and tracking. The platform’s visual boards and timelines offer an overview of ongoing tasks, making managing the product backlog and Sprint backlog easier. monday.com’s features enable Scrum teams to assign tasks, set deadlines, and update statuses in real time. Its reporting tools help conduct Sprint reviews and retrospectives. These tools allow teams to analyze performance and make necessary adjustments for continuous improvement.

Visit monday.com

Compare two popular Agile methodologies: Scrum vs. Kanban

Lean

Lean project management is an approach that focuses on maximizing customer value while minimizing waste. It’s rooted in Lean manufacturing principles, aiming to enhance efficiency and productivity. Lean methodology emphasizes identifying and eliminating non-value-adding activities (waste) in project processes, thereby streamlining operations and improving overall project outcomes.

Pros

  • Prioritizing the efficient use of resources reduces unnecessary expenditures.
  • Enhances team autonomy and quality of decisions by encouraging team members to take initiative and make informed decisions.

Cons

  • Oversimplifying processes creates potential to overlook necessary steps.
  • Transitioning to a Lean system can be complex and time-consuming.
  • Teams may require significant training and skill development.

When to use Lean

In logistics, Lean streamlines supply chain processes, reducing delays and costs while improving delivery efficiency. For construction, it minimizes waste and maximizes value in project execution. By doing so, it enhances quality and timeliness. By applying Lean principles, event planners can also effectively coordinate with vendors and handle client requirements. This can lead to successful, well-organized events executed efficiently and within budget constraints.

ClickUp is a robust project management tool that can effectively support Lean methodologies. It offers a highly customizable interface that allows teams to tailor their project management space to their specific Lean needs. The platform also includes powerful automation, docs, and goals features, which aid in reducing manual tasks (waste) and focusing on value-adding activities. Moreover, ClickUp’s collaborative features ensure that all team members are aligned and engaged in the Lean process.

Visit ClickUp

How to choose a project management methodology

Different methodologies offer varied frameworks, tools, and techniques, each suited to specific project types and organizational cultures. The right approach can significantly enhance a project’s efficiency and effectiveness. It makes sure that project goals are met within time, budget, and quality constraints while aligning with the organization’s broader strategic objectives.

When selecting a project management methodology, several key factors should be considered, such as project complexity and size, stakeholder and customer involvement, team size and expertise, industry standards and regulatory requirements, risk management, and adaptability to change. 

Larger and more complex projects may benefit from more structured methodologies like waterfall, which offer clear, linear stages and well-defined deliverables. In contrast, smaller or less complex projects might be better suited to more flexible and iterative methodologies like Agile.

Agile methodologies, which emphasize customer collaboration and frequent feedback, are ideal for projects where stakeholder engagement is high and requirements may change. However, waterfall methodology is highly recommended for projects with minimum stakeholder engagement and well-defined conditions.

Agile methodologies, for instance, are often preferred for smaller teams with a high level of expertise and autonomy, whereas larger teams might require a more hierarchical structure like that of a waterfall model. This approach provides a straightforward, structured process with defined phases and roles, making it ideal for managing the complexities and coordination challenges of larger teams.

Projects in industries with strict standards and regulations may require methodologies that provide comprehensive documentation and rigorous, phase-based planning, such as the PMBOK® Guide framework.

Projects with high levels of uncertainty or those operating in rapidly changing environments require methodologies that can accommodate change and effectively manage risks. Agile and Lean methodologies are well-suited for these scenarios, with their iterative processes and emphasis on continuous improvement.

Why does your choice of project management methodology matter?

In project management, keep in mind that there is no universal, one-size-fits-all methodology. Each project has unique challenges and requirements; thus, the methodology you choose must align well with its specific needs.

Interestingly, there are scenarios where blending two methodologies proves to be highly effective. This hybrid approach can leverage the strengths of each methodology, providing a more tailored and efficient way to manage and execute projects.

To choose the right methodology, you must first establish a clear understanding of the project’s scope, complexity, stakeholder expectations, and desired outcomes. The right methodology should help the project team achieve its goals efficiently and effectively. It’s not just about following a set of procedures; it’s about adopting a framework that enhances the team’s ability to deliver successful results.

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don’t pay us.

Featured project management partners

Browse all project management software →

Irene Casucian Avatar
Irene Casucian
Staff Writer
Irene Casucian is a research analyst for TechnologyAdvice, TechRepublic, and Fit Small Business. With sufficient experience as an HR writer, she has developed a profound understanding of various business needs that inform her research and analysis of HR platforms. Irene specializes in HR software evaluation and draws on her experience as a research assistant to provide in-depth assessments. Irene conducts objective research by gathering data to evaluate HR software performance across various HR functions, such as payroll, ATS, and onboarding, using carefully defined criteria to assess each platform’s effectiveness.